Two thoughts on this. 1) Private companies working with the government sucks but it is old news. 2) I used to believe the cost of finding a needle in a haystack was too expensive for anyone but the biggest criminals but modern AI made that much much cheaper to use for "show me the man, I'll chow you the crime"/
Yeah, I also learned the hard way: you want to keep something hidden from youth services (such as your own location) in Europe: USE A MESSENGER. Not Whatsapp.
But for everyone everywhere: just don't ever call or SMS. Ever.
Once enough people start doing that to make call records less useful, they can very easily also look through IP data records. All of these services establish direct IP connections with the device you’re talking to.
Why would I trust these american companies not to comply to requests from their government to implement backdoors ? None of these entities is trustable.
I think signal should not be treated this way. I don't personally need you to justify the others because i keep up with the news but what leads you to suspect Signal's operators of doing anything wrong?
What do you use? I have an impossible time convincing people to use Signal as it is. I'm curious what other options are there that people would be ok with adopting.
manufactured outrage. Where have all these so called journalists been for the last 10 years while Snowden revealed programs continue to subject every person in the US with panopticon level dystopian surveillance? Why are there only articles about ICE? Not defending ICE's methods and I readily agree that they are compromising the privacy of citizens and noncitizens alike, but there are dozens if not hundreds of programs that directly and intentionally target citizens in contravention of constitutional protections.
My current outrage predates Snowden to before Mark Kline to at least Echelon. There's nothing manufactured about it.
The same applies to Joseph Cox, who has been covering surveillance abuses for most of that same time.
I do acknowledge that most US news orgs gave bulk unwarranted surveillance a giant yawn until Edward Snowden dragged them into reporting it. They didn't seem to realize that - when you don't hold a reasonable PotUS accountable, you gift power to the unreasonable one that follows.
Wasted tax dollars are much less offensive than the fascism. Sadly nobody seems to care about it. ICE and the Feds working with phone companies, Feds working with the old Twitter, the government working with the legacy media all to show you just what you are allow to see. Brainwashing and control on every angle of every side.
Or how about a reasonable and humane immigration system?
Someone's visa expires? Serve them a summons to appear in court to make their case why they should be renewed. Court decides no? Give them a date to leave the country by. Failure to leave? Arrest warrant served by local police with a transfer to immigration authorities to perform the deportation.
Sure you might be able to poke holes in this plan, but I can certainly poke holes in a system where someone would be snatched off the street because some political appointee revoked their visa after they did something the current party in power didn't like.
10M people entered illegally from 2021-24. Giving every single one of them a lengthy hearing process is a logistical impossibility. They showed no respect for our processes anyway when they entered.
Are you suggesting these people entered and then left again? Because estimates only show a growth of 5-6 million in the illegal immigrant population from 2021 to 2025(which is not equivalent to the number of people who entered illegally, meaning to cross into the United States without permission. A large percentage of people without a legal status are those who entered legally and then lost their status.)
I think you're probably repeating a propaganda number that tries to frame people who were granted entry by the government as having committed a crime.
There were about 10M border encounters and some fraction, 5-6 million, were granted entry (that are known). I am not sure if this includes CHNV numbers and other airport entries. That's still a very substantial amount of people in a short time.
These people were paroled and given NTAs for asylum hearings ostensibly. NTAs do not grant legal status. Otherwise parole status can be revoked. There isn't any framing. Once parole status is revoked, subject to ongoing court challenges, they are in the country illegally.
Which means they didn't enter the country illegally. Their parole status being revoked doesn't warrant armed raids and long detentions. As much as right-wing media would like us to believe it, these aren't millions of dangerous gang members.
only on HN and Reddit can someone smugly say "it was only SIX MILLION new illegals under Biden. Bet you feel stupid now, don't you?" and think they're making a good point.
If you can't honestly and openly talk about a subject, then don't talk about it at all. "10M people entered illegally from 2021-24." is blatantly false. The fact you chose to use a blatantly false claim instead of facts shows you're not acting in good faith.
As a previous commenter corrected you, 10M is the number of border encounters, ~6M is the gross inflow, since you want to be pedantic. This kind of annoying sophistry prevents any "good faith" discussions from happening, but I think you already know that.
There is no incentive to do extra work. Nobody will make a fake hoop to jump through and I'm not sure a judge would even hear a request for a unneeded warrant. The alternative is a congress that can pass (or remove) legislation and actually represent us. But sadly HN is a very small "us" and a minority.
Yes, I would like it very much that federal agencies take their time and actually review cases, instead of sending US citizens to random faraway places or locked up on a whim.
Please refer to a founding principle stated by Benjamin Franklin himself: "it is better 100 guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer." [0]
But, to turn it around, of course ruthless and inhumane is what you seem to want.
This article is about a far more "humane" deportation strategy and you're still upset with it. I'd rather not stay beholden to old cliches if it makes illegal immigration de facto legal.
Two thoughts on this. 1) Private companies working with the government sucks but it is old news. 2) I used to believe the cost of finding a needle in a haystack was too expensive for anyone but the biggest criminals but modern AI made that much much cheaper to use for "show me the man, I'll chow you the crime"/
Get a warrant.
This story has vanished from the front page.
It seems to have disappeared from every subsequent page as well (at least to the 500s).
Yeah, I also learned the hard way: you want to keep something hidden from youth services (such as your own location) in Europe: USE A MESSENGER. Not Whatsapp.
But for everyone everywhere: just don't ever call or SMS. Ever.
This is why we Facetime Audio, Signal, or Whatsapp ONLY.
Once enough people start doing that to make call records less useful, they can very easily also look through IP data records. All of these services establish direct IP connections with the device you’re talking to.
Why would I trust these american companies not to comply to requests from their government to implement backdoors ? None of these entities is trustable.
I think signal should not be treated this way. I don't personally need you to justify the others because i keep up with the news but what leads you to suspect Signal's operators of doing anything wrong?
It's not about the operators. It's the fact they're an american company that need to comply to american laws.
I guess if you're an american you're stuck relying on your government, but I'm going to do everything I can to prevent it from having power over me.
What do you use? I have an impossible time convincing people to use Signal as it is. I'm curious what other options are there that people would be ok with adopting.
Matrix seems to be the better option currently available.
I keep wondering how the fuck ICE keeps getting away with all this shit, and then I remember this old Onion article: https://theonion.com/trump-claims-he-can-overrule-constituti...
manufactured outrage. Where have all these so called journalists been for the last 10 years while Snowden revealed programs continue to subject every person in the US with panopticon level dystopian surveillance? Why are there only articles about ICE? Not defending ICE's methods and I readily agree that they are compromising the privacy of citizens and noncitizens alike, but there are dozens if not hundreds of programs that directly and intentionally target citizens in contravention of constitutional protections.
> manufactured outrage
My current outrage predates Snowden to before Mark Kline to at least Echelon. There's nothing manufactured about it.
The same applies to Joseph Cox, who has been covering surveillance abuses for most of that same time.
I do acknowledge that most US news orgs gave bulk unwarranted surveillance a giant yawn until Edward Snowden dragged them into reporting it. They didn't seem to realize that - when you don't hold a reasonable PotUS accountable, you gift power to the unreasonable one that follows.
I'm not sure if the tax dollars wasted is more, or less offensive than the fascism.
Wasted tax dollars are much less offensive than the fascism. Sadly nobody seems to care about it. ICE and the Feds working with phone companies, Feds working with the old Twitter, the government working with the legacy media all to show you just what you are allow to see. Brainwashing and control on every angle of every side.
[flagged]
Or how about a reasonable and humane immigration system?
Someone's visa expires? Serve them a summons to appear in court to make their case why they should be renewed. Court decides no? Give them a date to leave the country by. Failure to leave? Arrest warrant served by local police with a transfer to immigration authorities to perform the deportation.
Sure you might be able to poke holes in this plan, but I can certainly poke holes in a system where someone would be snatched off the street because some political appointee revoked their visa after they did something the current party in power didn't like.
10M people entered illegally from 2021-24. Giving every single one of them a lengthy hearing process is a logistical impossibility. They showed no respect for our processes anyway when they entered.
Are you suggesting these people entered and then left again? Because estimates only show a growth of 5-6 million in the illegal immigrant population from 2021 to 2025(which is not equivalent to the number of people who entered illegally, meaning to cross into the United States without permission. A large percentage of people without a legal status are those who entered legally and then lost their status.)
I think you're probably repeating a propaganda number that tries to frame people who were granted entry by the government as having committed a crime.
There were about 10M border encounters and some fraction, 5-6 million, were granted entry (that are known). I am not sure if this includes CHNV numbers and other airport entries. That's still a very substantial amount of people in a short time.
These people were paroled and given NTAs for asylum hearings ostensibly. NTAs do not grant legal status. Otherwise parole status can be revoked. There isn't any framing. Once parole status is revoked, subject to ongoing court challenges, they are in the country illegally.
Which means they didn't enter the country illegally. Their parole status being revoked doesn't warrant armed raids and long detentions. As much as right-wing media would like us to believe it, these aren't millions of dangerous gang members.
only on HN and Reddit can someone smugly say "it was only SIX MILLION new illegals under Biden. Bet you feel stupid now, don't you?" and think they're making a good point.
If you can't honestly and openly talk about a subject, then don't talk about it at all. "10M people entered illegally from 2021-24." is blatantly false. The fact you chose to use a blatantly false claim instead of facts shows you're not acting in good faith.
As a previous commenter corrected you, 10M is the number of border encounters, ~6M is the gross inflow, since you want to be pedantic. This kind of annoying sophistry prevents any "good faith" discussions from happening, but I think you already know that.
And as the other commenter said, those people were let into the country by the government. That is not illegal entry.
More mind-numbing sophistry
The alternative is for them to get a warrant
There is no incentive to do extra work. Nobody will make a fake hoop to jump through and I'm not sure a judge would even hear a request for a unneeded warrant. The alternative is a congress that can pass (or remove) legislation and actually represent us. But sadly HN is a very small "us" and a minority.
> The alternative is for them to get a warrant
It's not an alternative. It's the bare, acceptable minimum because it introduces some accountability.
Obv
Which would make it logistically impossible to deport more than like a few thousand people. But of course that kind of kneecapping is what you want.
Yes, I would like it very much that federal agencies take their time and actually review cases, instead of sending US citizens to random faraway places or locked up on a whim.
Please refer to a founding principle stated by Benjamin Franklin himself: "it is better 100 guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer." [0]
But, to turn it around, of course ruthless and inhumane is what you seem to want.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
This article is about a far more "humane" deportation strategy and you're still upset with it. I'd rather not stay beholden to old cliches if it makes illegal immigration de facto legal.