Personal assistants are like the metaverse: an idea that tech people think sounds cool, but is completely useless for any practical purposes.
Most people simply are not so busy that they need someone to manage their calendar. And if you use these things to shop for you, I can virtually guarantee that you will be paying way too much, because vendors are gaming your gaming.
Here’s a specific use case I’ve successfully used an agent like this for.
I booked a family trip. The tickets are refundable up to 30 days out, which means if the price drops between now and then, I can get the lower price, but only if:
1. I notice the price has dropped
2. I call and get the lower price
In the past this was hit or miss. If I remembered and happened to check, I might get lucky. Now my AI agent is checking every day between now and the deadline. It already saved me $250.
I must live in some kind of metaverse; I'm still using a homegrown agent set up with telegram/whatsapp/email/command line and it does just about everything for me now, a few examples from this week
- patched my linux servers for the nginx vuln that dropped
- replied to my accountant with some invoices they needed
- took over annoying conversations with service providers, got a certificate of compliance I had been waiting for for weeks from one, and deflected multiple messages and voice notes a day about a taxi booking for next month he seemed to think was wroth messaging me every few hour about because he hadn't been paid yet
- reviewed some contracts and found several bad typos and wrong dates and fixed them
- did all kinds of odd research jobs in things I was curious about or needed information about like whether a black friday deal I was looking at was real or just a fake discount, put together a report on some tweet saying that the EU was sanctioning 12 journalists with a balanced take on why they were sanctioned, and prepared a GDPR request for my optometrist who is refusing to share my prescription with me because of some kind of weird company policy where they will only share that information if I go in person
I'm pretty sure the commercial agents for people who want it to 'just work' and don't want to set up a VPS with various coding agent subscriptions, and have have it engineer something with pi-durable etc, will mean that everyone is interacting with the world like this in the next 3-6 months.
I've happily provided oversight to implementing agentic AI at work on my current project. Excellent stuff, truly.
But I'm absolutely positively not giving an agent access to my personal files OR / write access to email OR ability to send it out OR access to my payment information.
I have no problem believing many people have successfully done that and not gotten burned. But just like a person who played and survived Russian roulette may be vociferous and excited, they almost may be statistically misleading from risk assessment perspective :).
It's still far too dangerous at this point. I've been seeing so many instances of people giving ai agents access to their communications platform only for it to do insane things like arrange a facebook marketplace meetup without confirming with the account owner and lying about the owner being there. As well as a recent one where someone asked it to organize an office move only to find it had been spamming all the contractors with stupid questions until the contractors refused to do business with them.
I want a personal assistant for things that have nothing to do with tech. On my to-do list: 1) research and select a new bumper for my truck, 2) find and install the right new large-sized weather stripping for my door's asymmetric gap, 3) make a dermatologist appointment, 4) look up thanksgiving recipes and make a shopping checklist, 5) find a new okay-seeming ortho through insurance and set up an appointment, 6) find a cheap vacation rental and the cheapest time to fly (or drive if flying is expensive and it's not too far), etc. There's a lot more on there, and I do not have enough time to do everything... which is why they exist on the to-do list.
I've not tried to set one up, because of the token cost, security issues, and vendor lock-in. But I absolutely want one. (I won't use Gemini's assistant, not so much for the vendor lock-in, but because every single interaction I have with Gemini shows it's infuriatingly stupid, even on Pro / High Thinking)
I'd consider myself fairly busy, but the tasks I'm busy with are simply not things that an AI assistant can help me with.
Can it sell some extra stuff for me on Facebook? This would involve taking photos of it, listing it, negotiating with people, scheduling when they would come by, talking to them when they arrive, and then handing them the thing. It can't just do part of it - the listing & messaging people isn't the hard part, and that's literally the only part it can do. (It can't schedule pick-ups, because it will not know what specific times I am available, because my time is not organized in such a way that I can commit it to a calendar.)
Can it mail things for me? I have things I have to pack and mail out to two friends. I don't need it to order stamps for me or print labels; I need it to package things into boxes, with padding because some of it is fragile, and then actually mail it off.
Can it take my grandmother to the hematologist? Can it take my child to karate? Can it make dinner? Can it take notes of last night's D&D session? Can it make sure, nightly, that my child has done her homework, check it for correctness, initial what needs to be initialed, and make sure my child's chores are done?
About the only thing it might be able to do is my shopping, if I take a picture of my shopping list, and have the local grocery store deliver it. Assuming it doesn't mis-read the list, assuming the physical shopper doesn't put in a wild substitution when they can't find the whole garlic. And then it can't put the groceries away for me, or tell me when they're on my porch.
This year I started using Amazon grocery delivery. At first I was very excited about it because I could browse through what's available and easily compare prices.
But then I noticed it actually took me quite some time to browse their catalogue, to search for "Milk" or "Seltzer" etc.
In a real super-market I just walk through my usual aisles and pick what I see I need from each aisle. I can inspect the freshness. I haven't even seen Amazon tell me the expiry datee of their milk.
Even for the stuff it can do, it seems like you'd have to spend an inordinate amount of time explicitly specifying everything you already know about your style and preferences for every little thing, and organizing every detail about your life into a way it can comprehend, that it isn't really saving you any time even in a best-case scenario.
For your examples, and one I completely agree with, imagine the effort that would be involved in putting every single thing you plan to do for the next month into some sort of calendar that an agent could understand, including the details about things that don't have a specific time but require coordination with a bunch of other factors that may not be easy to encode. I know for me, just the effort for this alone, not to mention privacy loss, in doing this would blow away any possible time saving for most of the possible use-cases.
Sure, as long as it can parse multiple people speaking at once, sometimes about different things. As long as it understands the context of the campaign thus far. As long as it can parse fake names. As long as it also has video of the table, I guess, for when we're doing combat on a grid, and also understands which minis represent which PCs and NPCs, and infers what's going on when we're not explicitly talking about what we're doing.
Sure, a few people are that busy. They already have personal assistants. Nobody else really needs this, and it can only do tasks that you'd do online. It's a lure to feed more of your personal data to Google.
This can open a "remote browser" and the AI can perform tasks in the browser. Here's a screenshot if anyone is curious, since there doesn't seem to be one in the article.
The thing I have with these "free" services is, they're not going to be free forever. The point is to get us hooked and then they'll turn the pricing up and add ads, sell my data or only recommend services and products that they have a paid deal with. I've become really hesitant to adopt American tech services now. They're always trying to trick you and scheme to get more out of you.
So I prefer investing in hardware to run an assistant at home. It's much more work and not as good I'm sure (though I haven't tried Gemini) but really it's the only way to know I'm going to be able to continue using it.
Ps the reason I'm calling out American companies in particular is that the business model of "let's subsidize the hell out of this and then milk the customers for all they're worth later" is not very popular here in the EU because there isn't as much venture capital. So things tend to have a business model that actually floats from the start. That might seem less innovative but it's also more ethical and tends to deliver longer-lived services to customers because the business case is there from the start.
I'm just getting really tired of that model. And the enshittification that results.
I’m a big Gemini fan but giving Gemini any task is a pain. It asks at every single step for approval, for example when I ask to update a bunch of tickets it often asks me for every ticket (even after setting it to “Always approve”). It constantly “loses” MCP connectors that are available in one message and aren’t in the next. Sometimes you have to @tag them sometimes not.
Google seems to be doing some weird classification thing where the available tools depend on what you ask in your message, and the intent filters the tools.
Tried Tasks many times for many different things and it’s still a very frustrating experience
Muse really showed me what an AI personal assistant could be. A single chat that just goes on and on and I'm using it only for managing things that can be delegated and done without supervising. I won't ask Muse to write code for me or even write my emails but it's great at listing things on marketplace, responding to messages there, and giving me updates on weather throughout the day.
" The primary culprit was our heat pump, which it turns out was kicking on around 4 p.m." ... How could gemini figure this out? My PG&E bills are pretty useless in telling what is consuming my electricity...
Signal is what you find interesting and what you click on, how often something takes for you, where do you generally create todos, when do you create todos, who do you creates todos with.
I can identify your home, your waking hours, what you are creating todos about, sell that to someone else to track your locations and find when your home is empty, what stages of life you are going through, ensure we make sure that people are working or not and if not then they face penalties, find people to listen in on your conversations or identify when to plan bugs in your house
> As Gemini becomes more capable, we continually advance our security defenses. When you assign Gemini a task, it uses Google Cloud’s Agent Compute Engine to work in a hardware-isolated virtual machine that’s dedicated to your account and never shared with other users.
It's fine! Only Google gets all your data, completely secure!
Very unlikely the functionality goes away. Very possible it merges with something else or changes name.
The whole AI space is brand new and very fluid. Teams are figuring out what's a feature, what's a product, what's a prompt, what's an interface, IDE vs. CLI vs. App, etc.
I am in my 60s and have absolutely no need for any of the current crop of personal agents. Considering the lukewarm interest from the general public, I wonder if the agent providers will actually be forced to pay users to use their agents
I am in my 60s and personal agents are changing how I do most online things. I create a bot when shopping for anything big, for trip assistance, for regular reports on key topics, for news on friends, family, favorite authors, etc. For tracking health metrics. I have one that is just trying to find the best day for me to burn a pile of yard debris. They wrap important apps for me, like Todoist, and let me work with them by voice. I have them talking to each other to build a status overview. I keep finding more uses. I at least consider launching one for any new non trivial project.
GrokBot had 418k users one month after launch. In October it was up to 800k paid users. According to Cloudflare, agentic traffic has recently exceeded human traffic on the internet. The consumer versions seem to be catching up.
Im on hourly electricity pricing just like it sounds Josh is. The power company sends countless emails and texts about not running AC etc in the afternoon, as if it weren't obvious already. Im skeptical Josh actually needed Gemini to figure this out or that looking at any number of electricity bills would help.
This only accesses information Google already knows about you. It's genuinely just a productivity tool. Is it a lure to get more of your information into Google so Gemini can use it? I guess. But it's genuinely just something to make people happy. I already use the full suite of Google services, so this is just a bonus. Unfortunately I don't think I can take advantage of it, but it is cool nonetheless.
Yes. Signal is what you find interesting and what you click on, how often something takes for you, where do you generally create todos, when do you create todos, who do you creates todos with.
I can identify your home, your waking hours, what you are creating todos about, sell that to someone else to track your locations and find when your home is empty, what stages of life you are going through, ensure we make sure that people are working or not and if not then they face penalties, find people to listen in on your conversations or identify when to plan bugs in your house
I would cynically argue that Google rarely if ever does anything for the happiness of anyone and that I assume this is to aid in justifying to managers and other leads productivity gains using Gemini. However, I would also cynically argue that Google has siphoned so much of my information from the pre-AI era that anything I put in now is simply redundancy.
Personal assistants are like the metaverse: an idea that tech people think sounds cool, but is completely useless for any practical purposes.
Most people simply are not so busy that they need someone to manage their calendar. And if you use these things to shop for you, I can virtually guarantee that you will be paying way too much, because vendors are gaming your gaming.
Here’s a specific use case I’ve successfully used an agent like this for.
I booked a family trip. The tickets are refundable up to 30 days out, which means if the price drops between now and then, I can get the lower price, but only if:
1. I notice the price has dropped
2. I call and get the lower price
In the past this was hit or miss. If I remembered and happened to check, I might get lucky. Now my AI agent is checking every day between now and the deadline. It already saved me $250.
this is really the only useful thing i've seen. cron as a service
Would you pay an agent for this the whole year?
Why would you need to pay?
Hmm I think it is really nice to wade through things like group chats that I don't have time for.
Why you in them then?
you should rethink everything if you don't want to catch up on messages from real people in your life
Claude, read this message from grandma and send a relevant reply.
I must live in some kind of metaverse; I'm still using a homegrown agent set up with telegram/whatsapp/email/command line and it does just about everything for me now, a few examples from this week
- patched my linux servers for the nginx vuln that dropped
- replied to my accountant with some invoices they needed
- took over annoying conversations with service providers, got a certificate of compliance I had been waiting for for weeks from one, and deflected multiple messages and voice notes a day about a taxi booking for next month he seemed to think was wroth messaging me every few hour about because he hadn't been paid yet
- reviewed some contracts and found several bad typos and wrong dates and fixed them
- did all kinds of odd research jobs in things I was curious about or needed information about like whether a black friday deal I was looking at was real or just a fake discount, put together a report on some tweet saying that the EU was sanctioning 12 journalists with a balanced take on why they were sanctioned, and prepared a GDPR request for my optometrist who is refusing to share my prescription with me because of some kind of weird company policy where they will only share that information if I go in person
I'm pretty sure the commercial agents for people who want it to 'just work' and don't want to set up a VPS with various coding agent subscriptions, and have have it engineer something with pi-durable etc, will mean that everyone is interacting with the world like this in the next 3-6 months.
It's a matter of personal risk threshold.
I've happily provided oversight to implementing agentic AI at work on my current project. Excellent stuff, truly.
But I'm absolutely positively not giving an agent access to my personal files OR / write access to email OR ability to send it out OR access to my payment information.
I have no problem believing many people have successfully done that and not gotten burned. But just like a person who played and survived Russian roulette may be vociferous and excited, they almost may be statistically misleading from risk assessment perspective :).
Crucially, YMMV and I accept that :)
Hmm I would not give an agent access to financials especially if it interacts with third parties directly. Too easy for it to get scammed by someone.
It sounds like a real foot gun.
It's still far too dangerous at this point. I've been seeing so many instances of people giving ai agents access to their communications platform only for it to do insane things like arrange a facebook marketplace meetup without confirming with the account owner and lying about the owner being there. As well as a recent one where someone asked it to organize an office move only to find it had been spamming all the contractors with stupid questions until the contractors refused to do business with them.
I want a personal assistant for things that have nothing to do with tech. On my to-do list: 1) research and select a new bumper for my truck, 2) find and install the right new large-sized weather stripping for my door's asymmetric gap, 3) make a dermatologist appointment, 4) look up thanksgiving recipes and make a shopping checklist, 5) find a new okay-seeming ortho through insurance and set up an appointment, 6) find a cheap vacation rental and the cheapest time to fly (or drive if flying is expensive and it's not too far), etc. There's a lot more on there, and I do not have enough time to do everything... which is why they exist on the to-do list.
I've not tried to set one up, because of the token cost, security issues, and vendor lock-in. But I absolutely want one. (I won't use Gemini's assistant, not so much for the vendor lock-in, but because every single interaction I have with Gemini shows it's infuriatingly stupid, even on Pro / High Thinking)
AI Personal assistant (ie.. Google secret agent) job is to report back to home base
Where do you live that people are "not that busy"?
I'd consider myself fairly busy, but the tasks I'm busy with are simply not things that an AI assistant can help me with.
Can it sell some extra stuff for me on Facebook? This would involve taking photos of it, listing it, negotiating with people, scheduling when they would come by, talking to them when they arrive, and then handing them the thing. It can't just do part of it - the listing & messaging people isn't the hard part, and that's literally the only part it can do. (It can't schedule pick-ups, because it will not know what specific times I am available, because my time is not organized in such a way that I can commit it to a calendar.)
Can it mail things for me? I have things I have to pack and mail out to two friends. I don't need it to order stamps for me or print labels; I need it to package things into boxes, with padding because some of it is fragile, and then actually mail it off.
Can it take my grandmother to the hematologist? Can it take my child to karate? Can it make dinner? Can it take notes of last night's D&D session? Can it make sure, nightly, that my child has done her homework, check it for correctness, initial what needs to be initialed, and make sure my child's chores are done?
About the only thing it might be able to do is my shopping, if I take a picture of my shopping list, and have the local grocery store deliver it. Assuming it doesn't mis-read the list, assuming the physical shopper doesn't put in a wild substitution when they can't find the whole garlic. And then it can't put the groceries away for me, or tell me when they're on my porch.
This year I started using Amazon grocery delivery. At first I was very excited about it because I could browse through what's available and easily compare prices.
But then I noticed it actually took me quite some time to browse their catalogue, to search for "Milk" or "Seltzer" etc.
In a real super-market I just walk through my usual aisles and pick what I see I need from each aisle. I can inspect the freshness. I haven't even seen Amazon tell me the expiry datee of their milk.
Even for the stuff it can do, it seems like you'd have to spend an inordinate amount of time explicitly specifying everything you already know about your style and preferences for every little thing, and organizing every detail about your life into a way it can comprehend, that it isn't really saving you any time even in a best-case scenario.
For your examples, and one I completely agree with, imagine the effort that would be involved in putting every single thing you plan to do for the next month into some sort of calendar that an agent could understand, including the details about things that don't have a specific time but require coordination with a bunch of other factors that may not be easy to encode. I know for me, just the effort for this alone, not to mention privacy loss, in doing this would blow away any possible time saving for most of the possible use-cases.
> Can it take notes of last night's D&D session?
Summarizing meeting notes is one of the most common AI use cases, so I definitely think that would be an easy one.
Sure, as long as it can parse multiple people speaking at once, sometimes about different things. As long as it understands the context of the campaign thus far. As long as it can parse fake names. As long as it also has video of the table, I guess, for when we're doing combat on a grid, and also understands which minis represent which PCs and NPCs, and infers what's going on when we're not explicitly talking about what we're doing.
Same here
Call me when AI can do my damn laundry
ah FUCK I also have to do laundry, and make sure my kid does their laundry!
Sure, a few people are that busy. They already have personal assistants. Nobody else really needs this, and it can only do tasks that you'd do online. It's a lure to feed more of your personal data to Google.
This is the “I’m on top of my shit so I don’t need that” attitude - easy to have when your pile isn’t large.
Now add kids, logistics, activities. The assistants are enormously helpful in coordinating multiple calendars.
This can open a "remote browser" and the AI can perform tasks in the browser. Here's a screenshot if anyone is curious, since there doesn't seem to be one in the article.
https://files.catbox.moe/42yl8v.png
https://files.catbox.moe/cyb4q2.png
https://files.catbox.moe/m0rmj5.png I hope I don't get banned for this.
Can't wait to ask Gemini Tasks to add 'figure out the difference between Google Tasks and Gemini Tasks' to my Google Tasks.
That was the witty comment Gemini posted for you? Kind of a self-burn haha
Chef I'm still recovering from the Google Notebooks, Gemini Notebooks and Notebooks in Gemini confusion..
And they are Google so they avoid all captchas and 403s...
yup. their "moat"
Very amusing that the "witty comment" is already downvoted and dead.
The thing I have with these "free" services is, they're not going to be free forever. The point is to get us hooked and then they'll turn the pricing up and add ads, sell my data or only recommend services and products that they have a paid deal with. I've become really hesitant to adopt American tech services now. They're always trying to trick you and scheme to get more out of you.
So I prefer investing in hardware to run an assistant at home. It's much more work and not as good I'm sure (though I haven't tried Gemini) but really it's the only way to know I'm going to be able to continue using it.
Ps the reason I'm calling out American companies in particular is that the business model of "let's subsidize the hell out of this and then milk the customers for all they're worth later" is not very popular here in the EU because there isn't as much venture capital. So things tend to have a business model that actually floats from the start. That might seem less innovative but it's also more ethical and tends to deliver longer-lived services to customers because the business case is there from the start.
I'm just getting really tired of that model. And the enshittification that results.
Please, it's Google. This service will remain free for a year, and then be unceremoniously shut down.
I’m a big Gemini fan but giving Gemini any task is a pain. It asks at every single step for approval, for example when I ask to update a bunch of tickets it often asks me for every ticket (even after setting it to “Always approve”). It constantly “loses” MCP connectors that are available in one message and aren’t in the next. Sometimes you have to @tag them sometimes not.
Google seems to be doing some weird classification thing where the available tools depend on what you ask in your message, and the intent filters the tools.
Tried Tasks many times for many different things and it’s still a very frustrating experience
Muse really showed me what an AI personal assistant could be. A single chat that just goes on and on and I'm using it only for managing things that can be delegated and done without supervising. I won't ask Muse to write code for me or even write my emails but it's great at listing things on marketplace, responding to messages there, and giving me updates on weather throughout the day.
> it's great at listing things on marketplace, responding to messages there
What sorts of things do you list, and how do you handle the rest of it - scheduling people to actually come and pick things up, and dealing with that?
" The primary culprit was our heat pump, which it turns out was kicking on around 4 p.m." ... How could gemini figure this out? My PG&E bills are pretty useless in telling what is consuming my electricity...
Is this a muse competitor? Tasks sounds like a one off interaction pattern. Vs Muse is more clearly understood as a persistent agent.
Why doesn’t tasks have an auto mode or a thinking level sub selector?
I’m bewildered and bewuthered by all the different AI surfaces and their (lack of) integrations.
I just tested it out and saw a new model 'Gemini Neon' in the dropdown. It required a Pro sub though.
Wasnt there another Google Tasks product?
oh good. more ways for google to track me
Signal is what you find interesting and what you click on, how often something takes for you, where do you generally create todos, when do you create todos, who do you creates todos with.
I can identify your home, your waking hours, what you are creating todos about, sell that to someone else to track your locations and find when your home is empty, what stages of life you are going through, ensure we make sure that people are working or not and if not then they face penalties, find people to listen in on your conversations or identify when to plan bugs in your house
> How we protect your data
> As Gemini becomes more capable, we continually advance our security defenses. When you assign Gemini a task, it uses Google Cloud’s Agent Compute Engine to work in a hardware-isolated virtual machine that’s dedicated to your account and never shared with other users.
It's fine! Only Google gets all your data, completely secure!
Over-under on this sunsetting in 6 months?
Very unlikely the functionality goes away. Very possible it merges with something else or changes name.
The whole AI space is brand new and very fluid. Teams are figuring out what's a feature, what's a product, what's a prompt, what's an interface, IDE vs. CLI vs. App, etc.
it's google.
I'd say most likely the other Google Tasks app, Google Tasks
I am in my 60s and have absolutely no need for any of the current crop of personal agents. Considering the lukewarm interest from the general public, I wonder if the agent providers will actually be forced to pay users to use their agents
I am in my 60s and personal agents are changing how I do most online things. I create a bot when shopping for anything big, for trip assistance, for regular reports on key topics, for news on friends, family, favorite authors, etc. For tracking health metrics. I have one that is just trying to find the best day for me to burn a pile of yard debris. They wrap important apps for me, like Todoist, and let me work with them by voice. I have them talking to each other to build a status overview. I keep finding more uses. I at least consider launching one for any new non trivial project.
GrokBot had 418k users one month after launch. In October it was up to 800k paid users. According to Cloudflare, agentic traffic has recently exceeded human traffic on the internet. The consumer versions seem to be catching up.
Im on hourly electricity pricing just like it sounds Josh is. The power company sends countless emails and texts about not running AC etc in the afternoon, as if it weren't obvious already. Im skeptical Josh actually needed Gemini to figure this out or that looking at any number of electricity bills would help.
Oh good, another way to feed data to Google that adds little value for myself.
Obligatory "if it's free, you're the product" reminder.
This only accesses information Google already knows about you. It's genuinely just a productivity tool. Is it a lure to get more of your information into Google so Gemini can use it? I guess. But it's genuinely just something to make people happy. I already use the full suite of Google services, so this is just a bonus. Unfortunately I don't think I can take advantage of it, but it is cool nonetheless.
Yes. Signal is what you find interesting and what you click on, how often something takes for you, where do you generally create todos, when do you create todos, who do you creates todos with.
I can identify your home, your waking hours, what you are creating todos about, sell that to someone else to track your locations and find when your home is empty, what stages of life you are going through, ensure we make sure that people are working or not and if not then they face penalties, find people to listen in on your conversations or identify when to plan bugs in your house
I would cynically argue that Google rarely if ever does anything for the happiness of anyone and that I assume this is to aid in justifying to managers and other leads productivity gains using Gemini. However, I would also cynically argue that Google has siphoned so much of my information from the pre-AI era that anything I put in now is simply redundancy.
I'd say this is more "setting a snowball free in hell"
[dead]
[flagged]
[dead]