Can I borrow a lunar rover? (2013)

(space.stackexchange.com)

18 points | by Skyfall106 3 days ago ago

16 comments

  • micw a day ago ago

    > Making one of the lunar rovers work would be more akin to restoring a classic car that hasn't been taken care of at all for years, it would require a lot of time and energy.

    Sounds like a 24h job for Mat Armstrong ^^

  • echoangle a day ago ago

    The first answer is fun but I don’t follow the argument. Just because the rover was left on the moon which can’t be claimed by anyone doesn’t mean it’s free to take. If I abandon a ship on the ocean, you can’t just take it and use it yourself either.

    • iterance a day ago ago

      You can actually claim abandoned property for your own (though maritime law is beyond me). The doctrine is called "adverse possession." While the requirements to qualify for adverse possession vary to a considerable extent, almost every jurisdiction has the concept.

      • adrian_b a day ago ago

        At the end of the discussion thread there are quotations from the existing international treaty, which specifies that the various objects that have remained in the outer space or on celestial bodies shall not be considered as abandoned, by they are still owned by whoever sent them there.

        • iterance 14 hours ago ago

          Very interesting, thank you!

      • rationalist a day ago ago

        Many if not all adverse possession laws exempt government property.

        • ktm5j a day ago ago

          But that's not about US government property that was left outside of the US. Our laws don't apply to the moon.

          • sandworm101 a day ago ago

            These laws are international. Property rights are recognized by every government.

            Prime example: Russian pilot defects to Japan, bringing his fancy MiG-25 jet with him. Pilot is a defector and is given refuge by Japan and the US. The jet is still property of the USSR and as such is returned... disassembled into boxes. As property of another nation, it was still USSR property even though USSR law was not applicable in Japan.

            https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defection_of_Viktor_Belenko

            • zzrrt 20 hours ago ago

              There's a spectrum with letting the Soviets come and take it on their own terms on one end, and Japan keeping it indefinitely on the other end. Taking it apart seems pretty far on the side that doesn't really respect property rights. It seems returning the pieces was more about diplomacy than truly recognizing their rights.

            • gus_massa 21 hours ago ago

              USSR had nukes, this makde their laws aplicable everywhere.

              Dough to dollar the CIA helped to pakage it and keep those 20 piece as souveniers.

    • sandworm101 a day ago ago

      This does come up in salvage cases. It is free for the taking if it has been truely abandoned, but not if someone is still actively looking for it. Also, property of states (ie the lunar rover) are not ever abandoned. So warships are generally never up for grabs so long as thier government still exists. Ancient roman vessels can be taken, but not british empire ships as britain still exists.

      • echoangle a day ago ago

        What if it’s not actively used but I’m not looking for it because I know where it is? If I anchor my ship to a rock in the ocean and leave it, I didn’t really abandon it and anyone can take it, right?

        NASA still knows where their rover is and I don’t think it would be free to use just because they didn’t visit and use it for some time, even if it were private property.

        • sandworm101 a day ago ago

          Your boat, if in danger, could be salvaged and you would have to pay the person who saved it but they dont automatically get to keep the boat.

          If you tied it up a court will presume you did so to come back to it. You protected it by securing it. You didnt abandon it to the sea.

  • ElUncivio a day ago ago

    [dead]

  • Freak_NL a day ago ago

    You can, but the Americans take grenade launchers along on their missions just for such an eventuality, so beware (tip: don't drive away in a straight line, swerve).

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50505271

  • torcete a day ago ago

    They belong to the whalers on the Moon. I don't think they will be happy about it.