It is impossible to sign up for ID.me if you do not use a smartphone. I know a person who is in this situation who has bonds in Treasury Direct that they now apparently cannot cash out. It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner.
The federal government says that all agencies need to offer logins via login.gov within two years [1]. For everyone's sake, hopefully this actually comes to fruition.
> It is impossible to sign up for ID.me if you do not use a smartphone
You can. I did it last week. I have a cell phone but use google voice as my primary phone number, which their system apparently doesn't like. I had to get on a video call as an alternative.
login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives so I was unable to create an account.
It is really irritating that organizations have started considering phone plans (voip vs prepaid vs postpaid) as fraud signals. This likely has something to do with information sharing agreements that each of the big wireless providers offer to sell your data. Really feels like yet another way for governments/companies to punish people who value privacy.
Yes, but not by USPS. You won’t get your mail undelivered just because you live in a sketchy zip code.
That’s the main difference between government-ran services and the private sector. The government has to service you if that’s their commitment, even if it costs lots of money or is stupid. Otherwise it’s disenfranchisement or even a free speech issue.
“Treat everyone from there as a criminal”. You’re not being treated as a criminal you just can’t use a VoIP number.
And for your example, if the neighborhood was known for car thefts, and a major theft happened, it would make sense to assume your suspect is from that neighborhood.
If you were building an ice cream shop and you do market research and discover a neighborhood has a higher than average ice cream intake, is it prejudicial to build your ice cream shop there?
Recognizing that a high rate of fraud comes from VoIP and then refusing VoIP is similar.
False equivalence. The more likely scenario is banning people who don’t wear shirt or shoes or who carry themselves in a certain way or behave poorly like a VoIP service
Being against this is like being against spam filters "just because it has all these spammy keywords doesn't mean it's spam". Granted, maybe the government should provide universal service but banning VoIP numbers is not ridiculous.
Well I would say that calling that "prejudicial" is walking into dangerous territory. By all accounts, from a statistical perspective, it only makes sense in this scenario to suspect some more than others.
As someone who works in security, I disagree! Security often comes at the cost of convenience, but it doesn't have to. My experience is mostly with IT security, but:
* Passkeys are an example of technology that is both more convenient and more secure. In this case security comes at the price of (a bit of) privacy, though.
* Memory-safe languages are much more convenient, and much more secure than unsafe ones. The price usually comes at a price of performance, but does not have to, and modern memory-safe languages are barely slower than C.
* Prepared statements in databases are both more convenient and more secure than joining strings. The price is a bit more complexity.
* OTP codes (google authenticator style) are at least as convenient as SMS codes, while being more secure. The price is... a bigger chance of locking yourself out, I guess.
* Passphrases are easier to remember and more secure than passwords. And a password manager is even more secure.
* Server-side HTML rendering with templates is much more secure and much more convenient than joining strings manually.
* Using managed services (managed k8s, cloud storage, s3, hosted databases) is more convenient than self-hosting. Security depends on your threat model - but you need a proper infrastructure team to manage updates/hardening. For small companies it's not viable.
* SSO with OIDC in corporate environment is more secure and more convenient for users and administrators than having a separate login everywhere.
* Docker containers are more convenient (to work with) and more secure than running things on bare metal on physical servers.
* Exceptions are easier to use and safer than signals, and as secure as return codes (different failure modes).
* Automated updates are much more secure and much more convenient than having to manually trigger system update every time.
* Building and deploying images with CI/CD is more convenient and much more secure than having developers deploy to production from a local machine.
* Traditional banking is more secure and more convenient than cryptocurrencies (lol).
I can go on. You may disagree with some of them, but surely you will agree that "more security = less convenience" is not an universal truth.
In the interest of technical correctness (the best kind of correctness, I hear), neither of those is a form of opting out. The proper traditional way is to relinquish your nationality through formal channels.
I hear it's about as easy as cancelling with Comcast.
In the interest of technical correctness, that is not a form of opting out because, as you said, it's impossible. That is what they want you to think is the way to opt out, so you'll be steered well away from channels that actually work.
Mechanically, that doesn't make sense. You have to show an ID to the government to open a PO Box, and the opener's info can be gathered through a court process. It creates a clear tie to the fraudster. If anything, a PO Box should have less fraud compared to a regular address that could just be a dead drop or similar.
For honest people, yes. Less honest people get a PO box with someone else’s id. Organized crime is quite organized, and paying some poor sod a few bucks to open a dozen PO boxes doesn’t seem incredibly complicated
I’m not downvoting or disagreeing with you. I don’t know exactly the exploit mechanisms in terms of id verification. but the result is very clear from arms length - PO Box addresses for accounts have massively higher rates of fraud.
It’s relatively easy (or was, might not be anymore) to make a fake ID that will fool someone who wants to be fooled, so you can get into a bar when you aren’t 21. All the doorman needs is plausible deniability - they showed me an ID, it said they were 21, I let them in.
An ID that will stand up to scrutiny by someone who really cares is not easy to fake. And an actual US Postal Service employee cares.
What's frustrating is that my VoIP number gives me powerful anti-spam tools - that's why I'm reluctant to get rid of it and start giving out my actual cell#!
You missed the part where I said "everyone who doesn't use the plan".
Facial recognition on everyone (something of dubious long-term security value given AI image generation) punishes people who don't use VOIP as well.
Also? Doesn't Google have an API you can query for phone number reputation that gives more fidelity on what is or isn't a trustworthy phone number beyond "VOIP bad"?
You say it as if it’s some sort of new information, but it’s not. Everything in life is a trade-off. I and many others would happily make that trade. Everyone that has done this has made the tradeoff. Not all business is worth pursuing.
That’s fine and that’s your choice. However it’s such a small percentage of legitimate customers that want to use voip, that it’s not worth the fraud loss to support them. Ie, it costs more to serve voip customers than they’re worth to the business. It’s our (and other similar services) choice to serve you too.
Fraud is a fact of life. Credit cards openly encourage fraud and try to mop up the mess after the fact; why can't we apply this to other aspects of life?
?
What benefit does a credit card company have to encourage fraud? They're the ones that will be paying out after the fact.
Perhaps a better way of seeing it is: They've found the balance between security and ease-of-use that maximizes revenue for the current point in time.
They could lock it down to requiring TFA + pre-authentication over a phone for every transaction etc etc etc, but the inconvenience to the vendor & customer, and cost to retrofit are probably huge. If it costs $1B to implement a technology that reduces fraud by $500M/yr, and transactions drop by $600M/yr due to the inconvenience, it's probably not worth it.
I'm 100% sure they must have huge fraud / tech departments keeping an eye on emerging fraud methods, counter-measures, etc. I would also bet they work with hardware vendors such as ingenico to keep rolling out new generations of countermeasures at hardware levels, so that when they have enough market penetration, they can start going from "optional" to "mandatory".
Usually fraud is paid for by the merchant. In fact, due to the various fees for everything from 3d secure to charge backs, fraud can be a profit center for the cards and banks (as long as it's not so much fraud the merchant can't pay)
> What benefit does a credit card company have to encourage fraud?
Lesser friction to use credit. Basic security has been an afterthought the entire time. Anyone with your card details can freely use it. Our payments system is a complete joke.
> They could lock it down to requiring TFA + pre-authentication over a phone for every transaction etc etc etc, but the inconvenience to the vendor & customer, and cost to retrofit are probably huge
Yes, security is inconvenient. But they don't even care about trying to come off as securing your money to begin with. There is simply no pro-human option available in the american markets.
that's because by implementing 3d secure too much they lose out on sales and impulse buys, making them less money. the gov has no incentive for this, clearly you have no idea what you're talking about
I've had a bank account for about a decade which forced me to add a phone number. A year or two ago, they insisted on "re-verifying" and then said the current number was invalid for whatever reason, which I assume means I don't have it registered as a postpaid number or have opted out of some data brokers. They still insist on sending 2fa codes to it though. I'm tired of getting stuck with paid, invasive, less convenient, less secure 2fa
Walmart deleted the house phone number I had and told me it was invalid. In actuality it is a home VoIP number that my wife also uses for her separate account and Walmart has decided that although multiple Walmart accounts are allowed per addresses a phone number can only be associated with one of them.
Since I did not desire any interaction with walmart on my cell phone I created a google voice number and gave them that instead which they bizarrely accepted. Then a month later they'd automatically updated the field to have my cell number, probably purchased from my credit card company or whoever!
Oh wow that's pretty bad. Is it possible you or your wife bought something in store and gave them the number, linking it by card number? I've had something similar happen where I bought an item in store, without giving them any extra info, and they sent an email receipt to the online account I had, which I'd most likely used the same card to buy online with before.
No, it’s because it’s a valid and useful fraud signal. It’s just one that has downsides that you personally do not like / are affected by. No model is perfect but some are useful. I assure you that this one is. It’s not for me to say whether or not it’s OK for governments (or the quasi-government entities that a government forces its people to interact with) to use signals that have this particular sort of false positive profile, but you’re being baselessly conspiratorial.
Lots of things are "fraud signals" which are actually just intentional class boundaries.
Your government can use Signal to organize bombings in Yemen, but if you use Signal, you're a potential terrorist.
Sure, a phone plan can be a fraud signal, and that fraud signal will be used as part of a modern digital redlining campaign, denying or restricting access to American citizens who either were born into poverty, value their privacy against the State, or both. It doesn't matter if fraudsters actually fit the profile, but the State appreciates hiding behind the plausible deniability of statistics.
If you use Google Voice because you are an expat (not sure if you are, just wanted to let you and anybody else in this position know about this), Tello is a US carrier that is $5 a month for a texting/calls no data plan, and does wifi calling and shared data calling over your local sim in whatever country you are in. The shared data calling is a bit of a pain to get working the first time, but once I got it set up, it works so well I can even call people on my US number while driving.
Tello looks like a normal US cell number to every government and two factor system, and works as a normal US sim when you are in the US. They also do not cut off your plan if you spend too long outside the US (unlike every other carrier I am familiar with).
Google Voice is the main alternative that people use, but 10-20% of SMS two factor systems do not work with it, mostly financial and government institutions.
The issue with paying money for something like this is that retaining the line - i.e. your ability to prove your identity and merely function in the economy/society - becomes dependent on this payment being made and received on time, successfully. Should anything get in the way of that, your digital life becomes at risk. That is not a great tradeoff.
Doesn't that describe 99% of SMS plans people use for 2FA?
If I stop being able to pay $5 USD a month from any Visa or Mastercard or future standard American payment system (and they will notify me if it declines), I have bigger problems in my life than my 2FA.
I had this problem when moving to US from Canada. Fortunately I had the foresight to transfer my Canadian number to voip.ms instead of giving it up entirely. Saved my butt a few times.
With a free service, retaining the line becomes dependent on the provider continuing to offer this free service, and their whims in deciding whether to continue providing it to you. There's no free lunch.
Sounds like the same thing as VPS providers that try to get themselves misclassified as residential networks. Problem is eventually the classification gets corrected.
It is a normal sim from a real carrier that takes a sim slot in a phone and does wifi calling when roaming, like many other carriers offer. It's just that this one doesn't cut your plan off once you've spent 6 months outside the US (you have to have US billing and activate it in the US).
>10-20% of SMS two factor systems do not work with it, mostly financial and government institutions.
And my local pub trivia company, and any radio promotions, and my vet's bespoke scheduling system, and my insurance agent's mandated client portal, and....
Let's face it, real world doesn't tolerate fake numbers regardless of their reasoning.
Is your cell phone a smartphone or a dumbphone? The person I was talking about is a retiree who uses a dumbphone that has large buttons, and nothing else. They don't have a web cam and are not tech savvy, so it seems like they are stuck. Treasury Direct and other agencies that rely only on ID.me really forgot that people like them still exist!
> login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives
Untrue unless something has changed recently. That one actually seems reasonable to me. You can create an account in your browser and then verify it in person at your local post office.
I did have trouble with login.gov being broken by my blacklisting of sketchy third party domains. An official government website should _never_ require loading resources from any domain that resides under a commercial tld. If our legislators were even halfway competent they would completely ban such practices. Call it the REAL Network Security act or something.
The verification options depend on the site you’re signing into. Some are willing to pay for the in-person verification service; others, like the IRS, are not.
Because a higher percentage of calls from Google Voice are fraud. It's really that simple, they don't care about you, all they care about is how well each available signal correlates with fraud percentage.
>How can my phone number be an indicator of fraud but some number someone paid five bucks for to get an esim is not?
I assume its because these "fraud" indicators come from 15+ years ago before people starting making scam farms racks out of cellphone parts running automated SMS scams.
Well that and now that copper phone lines are dead in most areas they have to suck it up and accept cellphone numbers anyway.
> I know a person who is in this situation who has bonds in Treasury Direct that they now apparently cannot cash out. It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner.
It is ridiculous that the government is forcing a third-party private vendor like this, but the Treasury Direct language is very clear that it's only your online access that is restricted - your friend can still cash out their bonds.
> If you do not sign up for ID.me, only your online access to your TreasuryDirect account will be restricted. Your account, funds, and investments remain secure. Please visit the FAQ page above, under the section, “Accessing TreasuryDirect After October 28, 2026” for more information on conducting transactions and retrieving tax documents without ID.me
Suspecting what might happen, I cashed out my treasuries before they switched to mandatory ID.me. Something about my setup broke its signup process partway through, even after I uploaded all sorts of personal information, and I would have been locked out otherwise.
Have you actually been on the Treasury Direct website and seen how insanely bad it is? The last time I used it was a year ago, but it rivals the New Jersey state tax website as possibly the most insecure, archaic, pre-HTML4 piece of crap I've ever seen. The fact that they recently bolted on ID.me makes me feel no better about whatever they're doing with data storage; these people can't hire someone who knows how to write a POST query. They could literally give any vaguely competent coder a $250k contract and rewrite the thing from scratch and it would probably be more secure than it is.
ID.me could meet IRS remote identity proofing requirements Login.gov could not at the time. Higher identity assurance is required due to historical rampant refund fraud, fraud that has cost billions of dollars.
> The government’s in-house digital identity service has not been without its share of controversy. A March 2023 GSA Inspector General report found that agency officials had misled customer agencies by claiming Login.gov met identity assurance level two standards set by NIST when it actually did not. GSA promised later that year to add facial recognition capabilities in order to meet that standard.
That's just a fig leaf to cover up vested interests. You can get a refund without ever presenting any ID if you submit the traditional paper forms by mail. So the IRS could have verified newly created online account by mail if they so chose. Or they could even have had you main in a paper form to create an online account. Instead we got ID.me and poor excuses for why login.gov was insufficient.
Because paper forms are friction and much harder to scale from a refund fraud perspective, as someone who has some context from interviewing with the IRS identity team as part of a US Digital Service interview loop ~10 years ago to combat this fraud.
You can review the GSA Inspector General reports on Login.gov and the deficiencies that led to slower agency uptake, they are public.
> … although GSA has publicly discussed the use of “selfies” as part of an identity-
proofing flow, we have made the decision not to use facial recognition, liveness
detection, or any other emerging technology in connection with government benefits and
services until rigorous review has given us confidence that we can do so equitably and
without causing harm to vulnerable populations.
> When we executed our initial agreement with you, we indicated that Login.gov would be
able to meet the IAL2 standards found in NIST 800-63-3. Our decision not to use facial
recognition technology, however, means that Login.gov identity proofing services do not
meet these standards at this time.
That doesn't seem to be a coherent response to what I wrote above. I pointed out that you can today claim your refund via paper forms without ever presenting any ID. So it is inconsistent that I cannot also register via mail the online account for doing same.
The reports are the proverbial fig leaf to which I refer. What happened with ID.me is a textbook example of grift.
IIRC you used to be able to get creds to access your IRS returns by some physical mail process a few years ago. They started preventing access from those accounts though to force ID.me.
If you fill out a paper 1040 form for your 2025 taxes, and you don't put a bank account and routing number to receive the refund, their online documentation says that you must create an account on irs.gov to provide that info and they will no longer send paper checks. In fact for at least one person who could not do those things, they eventually sent a paper check. But there is no form to claim your refund if you have already filed the 1040 form.
> The reports are the proverbial fig leaf to which I refer. What happened with ID.me is a textbook example of grift.
Believe what you want, it was a unilateral decision by a Login.gov representative out of equity concerns that had to be remediated with technology implementation per the Inspector General’s findings. Provide evidence ID.me was a grift, conversely. Without evidence, it’s a grift solely because you believe it is, and not based on any evidence. They were a commercial vendor who could meet the NIST standards required (800-63-3 Digital Identity Guidelines https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/63/3/upd2/final), and Login.gov could not because of a willful decision to deceive partner agencies about the capability.
> Our evaluation found GSA misled their customer agencies when GSA failed to communicate Login.gov’s known noncompliance with the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Special Publication (SP) 800-63-3, Digital Identity Guidelines. Notwithstanding GSA officials’ assertions that Login.gov met SP 800-63-3 Identity Assurance Level 2 (IAL2) requirements, Login.gov has never included a physical or biometric comparison for its customer agencies. Further, GSA continued to mislead customer agencies even after GSA suspended efforts to meet SP 800-63-3. GSA knowingly billed IAL2 customer agencies over $10 million for services, including alleged IAL2 services that did not meet IAL2 standards. Furthermore, GSA used misleading language to secure additional funds for Login.gov. Finally, GSA lacked adequate controls over the Login.gov program and allowed it to operate under a hands-off culture. We found that because of its failure to exercise management oversight and internal controls over Login.gov, FAS shares responsibility for the misrepresentations to GSA’s customers.
If you want your nation state identity provider to be taken seriously, it must operate seriously, which it was not doing, based on the IG investigation. It was the grift until adults were installed.
You're describing how grift works. It can't be totally out in the open - it nearly always requires a fig leaf of some sort. This has every appearance of a back room deal and here you are playing dumb demanding exhaustive evidence to believe what's sitting plainly in front of your face.
You've repeatedly failed to address my point about paper forms not requiring ID to use. As such the NIST standard is clearly nothing more than a thin excuse. If I wasn't assuming bad faith I'd say it was an example of an XY problem and that the people involved were simply incompetent. However I don't believe that at all.
If the IRS flags your paper return or refund, you will receive a CP5071 series notice or Letter 5747C and be required to provide identity documents and verification.
My point is paper returns and refunds are going away over the long term [1] [2], and Login.gov is here to stay after doing poorly previously (and is required to access your IRS and Social Security accounts). Make the best of it I suppose if allergic to the concept of government digital identity requirements. I have no strong feelings on ID.me, as a Login.gov user. If it sticks around, it is inconsequential to me as a consumer of US gov services. There is no evidence ID.me was a grift, only a vendor who could provide required services Login.gov chose not to provide and lied to their customers about.
> In accordance with Executive Order 14247, Modernizing Payments To and From America's Bank Account, signed on March 25, 2025, the U.S. Department of the Treasury, in coordination with the Internal Revenue Service and other federal agencies, is advancing the transition to fully electronic federal payments. This policy shift includes phase out of paper tax refund checks beginning Sept. 30, 2025, to the extent permitted by law.
I like facts, evidence, and the truth. Other opinions may differ. If surfacing all of the relevant facts is "playing dumb" you might be in the wrong place. Please, prove me wrong with evidence. But conspiracy theories without any evidence is not productive.
I have no connection to ID.me, have submitted PRs to Login.gov and have them accepted to improve user experience, etc. I like government services, delivered efficiently, broadly speaking. I don't like grift and corruption, especially in the context of government procurement, but am not going to call a situation or matter that until there is evidence of it beyond a preponderance of the evidence (ie "Would this accusation hold up in court?").
id.me is part of the industrial military complez grift.
it's a private company who long ago operated the army "company stores" on remote bases.
then it morphed into id.me, which was the login required for mil and vet benefits. and let me tell you, having a smartphone and doing a little dance on the selfie camera holding your drivers license is less worse then id.me have been before. anyway, it's a way to sell personel data for advertisers under the guise of benefits via commercial ads and coupons. awful gov sanctioned grift.
so yeah, it's in the core of the bipartisan schemes. they probably have both side in their pockets as this is going for a while.
Isn't it always "because someone paid off politicians via kickbacks to install their company as the solution for $$$$$$$$$". It doesn't matter there's an existing service. All that matters is there is $$$$$$$$$ to be made by making a new service and getting the contract to fulfil it.
> It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner
You're talking about the same government that frequently do multi-million deals with companies that the politicians in the government have ownership in? You're surprised they continue with exactly the same playbook, over and over again?
> The federal government says
Yeah, good luck with that. If anything, these last few years should tell you about how little "X says" actually means in practice, if there is no actual practical and concrete mechanism for forcing anything.
It’s wild because the ability to identify your citizens is one of the only core competencies that spans basically every form and manner of governance, from a huge country’s government to city council.
Like virtually every other function of government first requires establishing who someone is and whether they’re a citizen.
It’s shocking to give that up. If ID.me decides tomorrow they don’t actually like the US government (crazy, but crazy happens sometimes), think about how many US systems just stop working because they can’t tell if you are you or even a citizen.
Some marginalized communities don't have smartphones. I'd be scared of the tax man not including us on ID.gov but there's so little money to take because of the dismal poverty.
Oh come on, you’re saying this as if anyone who is working on that website understands what this means, or what id.me does. They ought to have an identity provider. They got a tender. They got an identity provider. People login. They are done.
It's not that they are doing bad things on purpose. It's actually a result of an acute mental condition called Idontcareism. Nobody cares, and nobody looks.
I don’t understand why we need id.me when login.gov exists, is less intrusive to sign up for, and is actually managed by the government. Why do we always need to insert a profit-seeking middleman in citizens’ dealings with the government?
The story I've heard is that the IRS had pretty unusual verification requirements and a tight timeline that login.gov couldn't meet in time given all the other agency wrangling on their plate. ID.me was willing to meet the timeline, to all of our detriment.
The least believable part of this is the government legitimately having a tight timeline for something like this. Just don't do it this year then.
It has the structure of a classic government contractor scam. Have the requirements written in such a way that you're the only one who can currently meet them and include a deadline that prevents anyone else from having enough time to comply.
The biggest fraud is the federal reserve inflating the money supply and making ebery single middle and lower income class family have 8-10% less purchasing power every year.
The Fed's inflation target is typically 2%, and the reason it's that rather than zero is that deflation is extremely bad but it's hard to get the number to be exactly what you want, and it's better to target 2% and sometimes get 0.5% than target 0 and sometimes get -1.5%.
Lately they've been targeting 2% and getting more than that, but not on purpose. Getting exactly the number you want is also hard in the other direction.
It also doesn't help that their nominal boss keeps yelling at them to stop raising interest rates, since "lower interest rates" and "print more money" are effectively synonyms.
60% of all dollars in existance have been printed in the last 6 years. If you still have any trust in the Fed and government my only assumption is that you're age 60+ and are living in the boomer world that doesn't have to worry about finances because you bought your house for $10k half a century ago.
The IRS started testing ID.me through a pilot program in 2017 and then used it for some specific programs, then started using it for every new online account in 2021.
That was long before DOGE came in and started wrecking things.
Used to be id.me for a long time. They recently revamped the website to support login.gov and unify auth across government website. (Probably a shout-out to National Design Studio in government website modernization driving it across the finish line.)
It sounds like login.gov is the one that was mandated during the second trump term, if I'm following the timeline correctly. That mandate just hasn't taken effect yet?
It sure is upside down world. Conservatives want a sovereign wealth fund, liberals want government control over industry, and no one pushes for see federal government.
The 2020 Trump administration made the decision and pre-funded the program, i.e. established a blanket purchasing agreement for the services. This essentially started a ball rolling that would have taken effort to reverse.
More detailed timeline:
In January 2020, under the Trump administration, the IRS determined that login.gov didn't meet its identity verification requirements.
In August 2020, still under Trump, the Treasury Department established a blanket purchasing agreement with ID.me. The IRS began ordering services under that agreement in June 2021, during the Biden administration, but the decision and funding had been established under Trump.
The ID.me procurement was done 17 months later, under the Biden administration, using the existing Trump-era purchasing agreement.
By February 2022, still under Biden, there had been criticism of the face recognition requirement, and the IRS announced that it would work towards adopting login.gov.
Login.gov achieved independent certification against the relevant NIST standard in October 2024. Trump took office three months later, and the transition never happened. It's unlikely to be prioritized under the Trump administration.
> inept government spans both parties
This is not ineptness so much as an ideological preference for using private companies to provide public services. This is often heavily influenced by well-funded lobbying.
For example, the 2005 proposal by Rick Santorum, to restrict public access to restrict access public to weather information that's available from commercial weather providers, was heavily lobbied for and funded by Accuweather. Happily, that one didn't become law.
Some that did become law, backed primarily by Republicans, include municipal broadband restrictions and the 2003 legislation for Medicare Part D which favored private insurers over federal price negotiation.
This Pew Research report shows that among supporters of the two parties, there's a strong preference (74%) among Democrats for government-provided services, with Republicans preferring commercial services by comparable margins:
This is great news. I had wanted to check something on my irs account, but am unwilling to authenticate to a .gov site with a .me site. (The .gov sites all say not to trust anything that isn't .gov !)
Although downthread it sounds like it won't accept my existing login.gov account, so probably I'll continue to do without irs.gov access.
This still requires sending your ID and face for additional verification through a third-party [0]. Even if you already have an account. Why the government can’t/won’t verify their own IDs they hand-out boggles the mind.
Login.gov does support verification through the post office for some government organizations. However, this is not supported for the IRS as best I can tell. Login.gov has pretty poor documentation though. Their phone number has no way to get to a human. I submitted a ticket asking but it appears they just closed it out.
Fun note. In-person to verification can’t accept passports. You can’t use a federal identification (passport) at a federal agency (post office) for access to a federal service (ex. SSA).
And Socure's terms require accepting an arbitration agreement and class action waiver. It's awful that a government-operated login service requires waiving your right to sue a private company.
It's even more absurd than that. You can mail in your tax return as a paper form without any sort of ID. Then the obvious solution for an online account is to verify it by mail. Yet suddenly facial scans are required "for security"?
What does one have to do with the other? They make the damn things but then pawn off verification to sleazy corporations. A standard ID has the same problem as a Real ID in this case.
I didn't mean to excuse ID.me. Just that the question seemed to presume a national ID card, or that it should be trivial for the federal government to verify a state ID[1]. IOW, it presumed something like REAL ID.
[1] At least without a sophisticated system in place with the states that allows verification without just handing over all the data.
Can you elaborate? First, nobody is required to carry around a driver's license; it's only needed for when you drive. And in the cases where you need to show a government ID, a driver's license (assuming it's a REAL ID) is just as good as a passport. So I don't really understand your position.
ICE has proven people's fears about the Federal government compiling databases and using facial recognition systems with handheld readers and massive surveillance networks so they can sic jack-booted thugs on people. It doesn't matter they were "targeting" illegals, every aspect of the fear was proven out in horrible fidelity, and nobody was able to pump the breaks before scores of people were murdered in cold blood. REAL ID isn't strictly necessary for that to happen, but it certainly helps[1], and it moves us in the wrong direction. There's a similar threat from states, but that's a separate problem and doesn't justify letting the Federal government have its way.
Also, they will make it increasingly difficult to move around without a REAL ID. This year I took a flight and forgot my passport. SFO was okay with me boarding without a REAL ID. But SAN (San Diego) TSA wouldn't let me through security without REAL ID or purchasing a $50 wavier, which I couldn't do because I couldn't access an e-mail account from my phone and I didn't have access to my laptop, so I had to rent a car to drive back, forfeiting my return ticket. But renting a car without a REAL ID is almost certainly on someone's list of things to fix.
[1] That's why they wanted it in the first place, to make it easier for them to hunt down terrorists and make it harder for people to slip under the radar of pervasive surveillance.
Agreed and also it's obvious overreach. State governments already collect and retain more information than necessary for drivers licenses. Why would we want to make things worse?
For international travel I have a passport, for driving my vehicle and purchasing booze I have a not-REAL-ID drivers license. Other than that only the bank gets to see my ID.
For anyone trying to leave TreasuryDirect because of ID.me: (Note the certified letter option in the third paragraph.)
"We will close your account at your request if there are no security holdings, you have no pending purchases, and if there is no tax information for the current year in it. After 24 months with no activities or securities purchased/held within your account the system automatically closes the account. Once the account is closed it cannot be reopened and a new account would need to be established.
To request your account be closed send us an e-mail from within your account, access your TreasuryDirect account and click "Contact Us" located in the upper right-hand corner of your screen.
You may also make your request in a letter with your signature certified by an authorized employee of a bank or credit union.
Please direct written requests to:
Treasury Retail Securities Services
PO Box 9150
Minneapolis MN 55480-9150
Please note, we will never ask for your password by phone, text, or email.
> After 24 months with no activities or securities purchased/held within your account the system automatically closes the account.
(emphasis mine) Looks like it says accounts are automatically closed after two years of non-use, which is different from actively requesting to close an account. (No doubt you'll have to have this argument in your back pocket for dealing with some indolent bureaucrat.)
Totally ridiculous that in order to access your savings bonds, you have to provide a private, for profit company your sensitive personal and biometric information, that they will turn around and monetize through spam and god knows what else.
The US gov (OPM) lost my biometric data, fingerprints, blood tests, background check info for security clearance, and even all 3 of my underage children's social security numbers, as well as mine and my wife's back in 2013.
I'm in nearly the same boat as you. I have 10-year bonds with ~6 years left.
I, however, did not sell them. But I refuse to sign up for id.me. I'm in a wait-and-hope stage that HOPEFULLY some future admin will roll back some of the corruption and reinstate login.gov.
And if they don't, in six years, I'll find some way to be very annoying about it. Not that it'll do any good, but at least I'll feel better about it.
I'd be surprised, personally. ID.me has been popular for years with places that wanted something more than just user/pass. E.g. military veteran status, to use something I'm familiar with. I don't see it getting tossed aside in the foreseeable future for login.gov.
I never got the appeal of Treasury Direct. I already have a brokerage account; just buy treasury bills and bonds from the brokerage account. Sure it’s a little bit more complicated than buying an ETF or mutual fund, but it is like an extra five clicks. It’s the same bonds. I don’t need a new login for my bonds.
Which is probably minimal appeal at this point. I bought them for a couple of years when inflation was going a bit crazy. I've thought of cleaning out my account but given the annual contribution limit, I should probably keep what I have for whatever tiny diversification it gives me even if I don't make further contributions.
Ex-pat here. Authenticating to ID.ME from Europe was interesting. After some online prep I made an appointment for a video check where I spoke to a rep and showed my ID cards.
The video quality was only so-so and I had a suspicion that the rep was AI-generated... but I did not dare voice this.
ID.me was the only SSO service my mother could actually use, because she has a prepaid cell and VOIP for household phone, both of which login.gov rejects on principle.
login.gov's privacy act statement says mobile carriers may provide customer type and billing type, as well as subscriber name and address, network, account status and imsi and imei. https://www.login.gov/policy/our-privacy-act-statement/
That's pretty wild because I don't remember consenting to my phone company handing out that information to anyone ever. Do they only do this for the US federal government or are they also illicitly sharing my personal data with BigTech when I "verify" an account via SMS?
I hate to tell you, but your cell phone company sells incredibly detailed information about you to basically anyone who asks (pays a small fee through a broker). You would be shocked what I can know about you for $0.10 and your phone number.
Consent or no.
Sorry for the late reply. You can’t, they sell it to brokers and then 3rd parties offer b2b services with the data. Obstinately for phone number ownership reasons, but I’m sure for all kinds of other reasons.
I worked in an sms heavy tech company, in about 2018 one of these vendors pitched us with a demo for phone ownership verification. I was horrified what it returned. Full demographic and household demographic info and pii for anyone that had owned that number or was in the address that that number had ever belonged to. Incomes, all kinds of stuff. On any number you wanted to input. There’s a reason these companies operate quietly as needtoknow in the b2b space and don’t have public webpages showing what they offer. People would be horrified.
Major carriers let you download a report of personal data they collect, and categories of third parties they share it with. Smaller carriers... I wouldn't bet on it.
- Verizon: Log into your account and navigate to the Verizon Privacy Dashboard (https://www.verizon.com/privacy/) to access your data report and turn off "Custom Experience" and "Business & Marketing Insights"
Also tell your representatives to make it illegal to sell your data without an explicit opt-in. You can erase the data from a data broker, but they'll just buy it again.
Some video games require phone verification to prevent cheating and they stopped accepting postpaid numbers. So it's safe to assume it's available to every bum on earth that can rub two pennies together.
Phone companies register if your number is part of a long-term contract. Anyone can pay to look that up in a database. If you're not part of a long-term contract, you're "high-risk", and thus your number gets rejected. So you're forced to pay for the phone company's "low-risk", more expensive, contract, to get a number that is "acceptable".
I had to use this horrible website to retrieve my Identity Protection PIN from the IRS website in order to file my taxes. Their automated system didn't work and I had to wait days to get on a video call to get verified. I never saw any option for login.gov; my only option was to use this private service with a domain name based in Montenegro. Truly bonkers
I was completely unable to complete ID.me verification. ID.me can't cope with the fact that the address printed on my ID is one digit different from the one on my utility bills (because logical and physical streetnumbers don't always correspond)...
I've been audited by the IRS almost every year since I was 18 years old. This privacy violation is incredibly horrible but it's not surprising to me. The IRS is a corrupt organization that supports the rich paying no taxes while harassing the common people for nickels and dimes.
The IRS is responsible for enforcing the code, not writing the law.
You need a new accountant if you're getting flagged every year. The IRS is not well known for auditing low-revenue businesses (per 'nickels and dimes').
you go from hiding from the IRS hoping you never get an inconvenient bill from them
to collaborating with the IRS with them signing off on how you’re not going to pay them
I’m personally motivated by this arrangement. The IRS is several different business units that don’t know how the other one moves. And the tax code by number (ie. Section 400 for tax deferrals like retirement plans vs Section 500 for tax exempt organizations) is an entirely different universe than the other number. Nobody gets a fully clear picture except you for the arrangement you’ve synthesized for yourself
Add a lawyer to the mix and its impossible for the government to know what your legal strategy was to disagree with it in a court. The expense alone - of finding out or being wrong - is a deterrent, the energy is focused on cheaper defendants that took a tax credit for being poor
A true audit would be rare. This involves interacting with a human Revenue Agent. Some people get a routine computer-generated letter from the IRS (typically "CP 2000" letter) identifying mis-matches with 3rd party reported data. These letters are not considered audits in the traditional sense.
I'd like to understand why ID.me doesn't let non-government companies use them as an identity provider. I would love, love, LOVE if I could use a social media site which guaranteed that every user was a US citizen or green card holder.
Anonymity has its benefits, and I don't think it should be outlawed for SURE, but I should have the option of being able to use some social media site that any US citizen could participate in and know that everyone else on the site was a US citizen.
> I would love, love, LOVE if I could use a social media site which guaranteed that every user was a US citizen or green card holder.
I wouldn't assume that they verify or share US immigration status for any of their clientele, governmental or private. Being ID.me-verified says approximately nothing about US immigration status.
If ID.me sees a valid unexpired US passport or green card, then sure, they know the US immigration status which that document indicates. But there are plenty of cases where they don't know that.
If they see a REAL ID-compliant driver license/state ID, they know the person showed verifiable evidence of lawful presence in the US at the time the application was submitted to the state, but not what the corresponding US immigration status was then or what it is now. If they see a Social Security Number, they know the person either has current or past US work authorization or current or past entitlement to a benefit which requires having a Social Security Number, but nothing else about the person's current or former US immigration status.
The other documents ID.me accepts say even less on the topic.
When they see a foreign passport as the primary ID, the person's current US immigration status could range from none at all to US-foreign dual/multiple citizen to anywhere in between. And they also accept non-REAL ID-compliant driver licenses and state IDs, which are perfectly legitimate and valid for most purposes, and those usually don't indicate immigration status either. Yes, undocumented migrants can get them. But so can any other immigration status. My parents have been US citizens their whole lives and only just switched their driver licenses to REAL ID this year, because their US passports served the few purposes for which REAL IDs are required and so they kept deferring the complex procedure of making that switch instead of easily renewing the old type.
> If every account has to be tied to a real person, the cost of obtaining bots accounts will rise exponentially
Nope. Dedicated states love building fakes and passing these identity challenges. That doesn't stop the bots. Also, scammers perform these identity validations with vulenerable populations. (They even sign up their victims for KYCed bitcoin accounts)
Well, the examples you provide just show how much the cost is higher to get an account. And over time, id.me could perform additional security measures which increase the cost even further.
To be clear, I don't like that future, but I suspect that some variation of it will be in demand given the amount of bots exponentially rising.
It doesn't stop the original problem, it just makes the scams worse.
Foreign states mint fake documents all the time, scammers force their victims in to lengthy KYC processes and it gives them more leverage to do even more damage. The companies who invest in this crap end up getting a "get out of jail card for" well we implemented something how can we be responsible.
But not always authentically so. Pretty much every election cycle someone turns up a network of foreign bots engaging in political debate on the various social networks (and not just in the US either - UK and Australia both have had the same issue)
There are less-charitable explanations: the OP could want to explicitly exclude undocumented immigrants (and anyone else without an up-to-date government ID), from their social networks.
I wasn't aware until just now that id.me is not a government-provided service!
What a bewildering state of affairs; it looks like SSA and IRS both allow login.gov (which if I had seen it when I signed in initially I certainly would have used).
Is there a way to migrate off of id.me and use login.gov instead?
For both SSA and IRS you can simply select Login.gov for login and it you will be sent to login.gov where it will ask of you want to link you {SSA|IRS} account.
Say yes and it will go through the verification procedure. When that finishes you will then be able to use Login.gov for login.
Your ID.me login will still work, so if you don't want to keep it as a back up I believe you can login to your ID.me account and somewhere in the settings you can tell it to unlink from {SSA|IRS}.
I recently tried this. I did SSA first, then IRS, which is probably not the best order, for reasons I'll describe below.
At some point in the Login.gov verification flow you have a choice between entirely online or taking taking you ID card to a post office. If you do entirely online it goes like this. (I'm doing this from memory so there may be minor errors in this).
• You enter your phone number and they text you a link.
• The link opens an app that takes a photo of the front and back of your ID card, and then takes a selfie.
• Then back in the browser where you started all this they ask for a phone number that is associated with you, and they do some checking to verify that.
NOTE: this very likely will fail if your phone plan is a prepaid plan. It failed for my Verizon Visible number. At that point you can cancel, start over, and opt for going to a post office.
On the post office path you are given a bar code and instructed to the post office you selected, and show them the bar code and your ID card. They scan the bar code and spend a minute or so doing something on their computer. An hour or so later you'll get an email saying you have successfully verified your ID with {SSA|IRS}.
NOTE: if you end up having to do the post office approach because of a prepaid phone, the good news is that the this will be remembered and in future verifications it should work with the online path.
When I then did the IRS it was the same as above except online verification worked with my prepaid Verizon Visible number.
After all this I then tried it at Medicare.gov. With that when Medicare.gov sent me to Login.gov and it asked if I wanted to link my Medicare account and I said yes--it redirected back to Medicare.gov and I was logged in.
So how come I had to do separate verifications for SSA and IRS and then no more verification for Medicare.gov?
From what I've found out since, apparently a good mental model for how this works is that when it has you verify something that sets a flag on your account that says you've passed that verification and when. When you try to link an account at an agency it knows what flags the agency requires. If there are any the agency requires that you do not have you have to verify those.
The agency can require that certain flags be new. If you already have that flag it will be reverified.
IRS requires the ID and selfie uploads to be new, so I had to do them again even though I already had those flags from the SSA verification. Medicare.gov does not require anything to be new and only requires a subset of the flags SSA and IRS require, so I wasn't asked to do anything when linking that.
Hence, if you do IRS first, then SSA should be a lot simpler because all the flags SSA requires should be there and SSA does not require them to be new.
I went into TreasuryDirect, redeemed all my I-bonds, and cancelled all my reinvestments on everything else right before this went into effect. Luckily I mostly had short-term notes, so they'll be back in my accounts in a few months. I'm sure it's just a drop in the bucket - all the "real money" holders will go through whatever dance the fed says - but is this really what we should be doing as interest rates rise to a 20 year high?
The whole point of using TreasuryDirect was to avoid counterparty risk with a private company by going directly to the treasury. If I now need id.me approval to access my funds, there's no point for me. I might as well buy treasuries through a broker instead, with all the extra benefits that brings.
I don’t bother calling my reps about many things, but I have called several times about this one. It’s insane that I need to hand over this amount of PII to a private company to log in to the fucking IRS.
At one point when I did this I got an instruction that was, not verbatim, but no more detailed than: "Go on your phone and download the ID.me app." Putting aside the absurdity of needing to go on my phone, it wasn't a QR code to scan with a link, or some website to go to that links to the right app, just throwing me out there on my own like that. I know enough to feel red flags, and to go to the Google Play store and carefully check the provenance of what I find in the search results there, but they're gonna have normies doing a web search for "ID.me app" and tapping the first ad in the results.
Post office experience is a breeze, have done it to test it. Should just need to show the barcode provided by login.gov to the clerk and an acceptable form of ID specified.
It seems a little crazy that the government would put up roadblocks to accessing bonds people bought.
Our government has a debt problem and interest rates on bonds are comparatively high, you'd think they want it to be as easy as possible for the public to buy up debt and help fund our deficit spending.
I couldn't sign into my IRS account without enrolling into ID.me earlier this year when I had to get info on my tax return. I'm talking march of this year.
So many problems here... 1) It is insane that there is a specific carve-out that these terms don't apply to you if you're a government worker. Aka, politician. 2) According to this, the Treasury has so far paid $93M for ID.me, and is contractually on the hook for up to 1 billion. Mind you, that money being spent is the taxpayer dollars of the citizens now being forced to use this service. A service that the government already runs (login.gov) without needing to pay a corporation. 3) There are citizens who bought Treasury products with the expectation that they could cash them out when they needed, without an expectation that they'd be giving implicit consent in the future to any arbitrary legal terms from a for-profit corporation.
Political corruption and corporate exploitation. Just another day in the USA.
America really is a parody in many ways. Thought Soviet Russia had its hand in people's pockets? In United States, you have to pay Company for right to pay Government! (through 3rd party login vendors and through tax prep software lobbying to prevent simplification of your tax filing)
Your comment is being flippant with some pretty serious concerns.
Costs don't always present in dollars at the transaction time. There's downside risk to not being able to log into ID.me / IRS online systems.
(1) ID.me doesn't have a 100% accuracy rate. I remember lots of problems when states used them for welfare benefits.
(2) IIRC it raises the requirements for which devices you must use to login (this is old info, so it may no longer apply).
(3) Paper filing is not nearly as fast as online filing, so it could mean weeks of the government holding onto your money longer than needed.
(4) CPAs can charge a lot more than TurboTax / H&RBlock for the simplest filings. Being stuck with paper as the only option is a financial penalty.
(5) The parent mentioned Intuit lobbying to kill the US government's free IRS website filing. That's is even more work that the average OECD country where the government is responsible for doing your taxes for you, as opposed to the US where the time and cost is a burden on the citizen/worker.
Simple tax filings don’t require H&R Block. I used to file my taxes on paper when I was young and my affairs simple. Most workers need only file a 1040 EZ, which is simple as pie; with capital gains on investments you’ll need a regular 1040, which is also not too difficult. It’s when you’ve got Schedule K partnerships in multiple states that you start to need help on taxes, and at that point you probably need an actual CPA instead of H&R Block. Those low-end tax places are the real financial penalty, not a CPA. They exist only because people are too lazy to fill out a 1040 like we all used to have to do.
> Most workers need only file a 1040 EZ, which is simple as pie
The 1040ez was eliminated in 2018 when the regular 1040 was significantly simplified (like down to 1/3 or 1/4 of its previous length). The 1040 has grown a little since then, but is still shorter than it was before 2018.
>Costs don't always present in dollars at the transaction time.
All the factors you've listed are just generic good governance issues, nothing to do with soviet union/communism vs US/capitalism OP was talking about.
Free for consumers means passed to consumers in an opaque way. There is zero reason for commerce to be involved in paying my taxes, or to be required to intermediate software access to services.
Is it just me, or is this system poorly thought out?
Like, let's say somebody manages to create an account in my name on ID.me. What has that proven? It relies on shared secrets known to be leaked, like my SSN and a photo of my license. It relies on additional information it can't possibly use to identify me without millions of false positives/negatives when applied across the country (address, phone number, etc), all of which are available from the same data brokers they're using in the first place (whether the info is correct or not) if they're validating against third-party data sources rather than vibes.
Twitter and Facebook can get away with that kind of nonsense if they want, but as a service securing quite large bond and tax refund accounts I'm pretty sure we want to do better.
I think this is a case of the government outsourcing critical functions to private companies, which can be dangerous. ID.me's terms are concerning, especially the arbitration clause. It's worrying that they're handling government verification data. Login.gov seems like a better option, but it's not widely known. I wonder how many people are being locked out of their own money because of this. It's a mess
As sso providers go, I have to say I always found Id.me quite nice to use. It always seems to send the 2fa code faster than other providers, and has so far never caused me problems. I am slightly surprised to see the hate for them in the comments. Aside from being a private company, what is the problem with id.me?
It is impossible to sign up for ID.me if you do not use a smartphone. I know a person who is in this situation who has bonds in Treasury Direct that they now apparently cannot cash out. It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner.
The federal government says that all agencies need to offer logins via login.gov within two years [1]. For everyone's sake, hopefully this actually comes to fruition.
[1] https://www.nextgov.com/digital-government/2026/08/white-hou...
> It is impossible to sign up for ID.me if you do not use a smartphone
You can. I did it last week. I have a cell phone but use google voice as my primary phone number, which their system apparently doesn't like. I had to get on a video call as an alternative.
login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives so I was unable to create an account.
Overall the process was extremely irritating.
It is really irritating that organizations have started considering phone plans (voip vs prepaid vs postpaid) as fraud signals. This likely has something to do with information sharing agreements that each of the big wireless providers offer to sell your data. Really feels like yet another way for governments/companies to punish people who value privacy.
> This likely has something to do with [selling your data]
It seems much more likely it has to do with certain phone plans having drastically higher rates of fraud.
Certain neighborhoods have drastically higher rates of crime. That doesn't make it okay to treat everyone from there as a criminal.
(Or in this case, disenfranchise them of access to government services.)
Unlike a private business, who can decide not to do business in the high crime district, the federal government needs to serve every single citizen.
Whether it's OK is mostly unrelated to whether it's the reason it's done.
I uh have some news for you.
Shipping address is absolutely used as a fraud signal.
Yes, but not by USPS. You won’t get your mail undelivered just because you live in a sketchy zip code.
That’s the main difference between government-ran services and the private sector. The government has to service you if that’s their commitment, even if it costs lots of money or is stupid. Otherwise it’s disenfranchisement or even a free speech issue.
You’re making several logic errors.
“Treat everyone from there as a criminal”. You’re not being treated as a criminal you just can’t use a VoIP number.
And for your example, if the neighborhood was known for car thefts, and a major theft happened, it would make sense to assume your suspect is from that neighborhood.
No, it wouldn’t “make sense”, it would be “prejudicial”.
If you were building an ice cream shop and you do market research and discover a neighborhood has a higher than average ice cream intake, is it prejudicial to build your ice cream shop there?
Recognizing that a high rate of fraud comes from VoIP and then refusing VoIP is similar.
What about banning people from visiting your ice cream shop if they live in a certain area?
False equivalence. The more likely scenario is banning people who don’t wear shirt or shoes or who carry themselves in a certain way or behave poorly like a VoIP service
Being against this is like being against spam filters "just because it has all these spammy keywords doesn't mean it's spam". Granted, maybe the government should provide universal service but banning VoIP numbers is not ridiculous.
Well I would say that calling that "prejudicial" is walking into dangerous territory. By all accounts, from a statistical perspective, it only makes sense in this scenario to suspect some more than others.
Not it wouldn’t be, it would be entirely logical.
Well it's a good thing we're not talking about that then.
Those two things are not the same.
They are the same, and both are largely due to decades of redlining and disenfranchisement and convincing people like you that redlining stopped.
Of course they aren't: it's an analogy, as you know. If you'd like to argue the point, you'll need to actually say something.
That may be, but nobody but you and your phone carrier should have access to information about your plan.
You are being too optimistic:
That relationship is not true. It might be true at the efficiency frontier. Maybe. I don't know.
But it's very easy to compromise on convenience without gaining any security and vice versa.
As someone who works in security, I disagree! Security often comes at the cost of convenience, but it doesn't have to. My experience is mostly with IT security, but:
* Passkeys are an example of technology that is both more convenient and more secure. In this case security comes at the price of (a bit of) privacy, though.
* Memory-safe languages are much more convenient, and much more secure than unsafe ones. The price usually comes at a price of performance, but does not have to, and modern memory-safe languages are barely slower than C.
* Prepared statements in databases are both more convenient and more secure than joining strings. The price is a bit more complexity.
* OTP codes (google authenticator style) are at least as convenient as SMS codes, while being more secure. The price is... a bigger chance of locking yourself out, I guess.
* Passphrases are easier to remember and more secure than passwords. And a password manager is even more secure.
* Server-side HTML rendering with templates is much more secure and much more convenient than joining strings manually.
* Using managed services (managed k8s, cloud storage, s3, hosted databases) is more convenient than self-hosting. Security depends on your threat model - but you need a proper infrastructure team to manage updates/hardening. For small companies it's not viable.
* SSO with OIDC in corporate environment is more secure and more convenient for users and administrators than having a separate login everywhere.
* Docker containers are more convenient (to work with) and more secure than running things on bare metal on physical servers.
* Exceptions are easier to use and safer than signals, and as secure as return codes (different failure modes).
* Automated updates are much more secure and much more convenient than having to manually trigger system update every time.
* Building and deploying images with CI/CD is more convenient and much more secure than having developers deploy to production from a local machine.
* Traditional banking is more secure and more convenient than cryptocurrencies (lol).
I can go on. You may disagree with some of them, but surely you will agree that "more security = less convenience" is not an universal truth.
In which case the customer's next action should be to divide by zero.
Please let me know how to opt out of the government interactions.
The two traditional methods are getting together a big enough mob to vote out the incumbents, and something similar but with guillotines.
In the interest of technical correctness (the best kind of correctness, I hear), neither of those is a form of opting out. The proper traditional way is to relinquish your nationality through formal channels.
I hear it's about as easy as cancelling with Comcast.
In the interest of technical correctness, that is not a form of opting out because, as you said, it's impossible. That is what they want you to think is the way to opt out, so you'll be steered well away from channels that actually work.
Do you know of any cable companies that aren't trash?
So the solution is to punish everyone who doesn't use that plan to reduce fraud on those who do. Right. Great.
I'm not particularly convinced fraud reduction is the primary motive here.
I work at a large fintech. It’s absolutely fraud. VOIP and portable numbers are a massive fraud correlation. Wish it weren’t so but it is.
Same as PO Boxes. Sadly, because I’ve been in a situation where I legitimately needed to use one as my address. Alas scammers ruin everything
Mechanically, that doesn't make sense. You have to show an ID to the government to open a PO Box, and the opener's info can be gathered through a court process. It creates a clear tie to the fraudster. If anything, a PO Box should have less fraud compared to a regular address that could just be a dead drop or similar.
For honest people, yes. Less honest people get a PO box with someone else’s id. Organized crime is quite organized, and paying some poor sod a few bucks to open a dozen PO boxes doesn’t seem incredibly complicated
If they're using someone else's ID to get a PO box, couldn't they use someone else's ID to get a phone line?
Yes, but nobody said that it’s a perfect correlation. That doesn’t detract from it being a huge fraud indicator.
It's not just an ID, it's other forms required as well. I got one at some point, and it was a pain with the documentation required.
I’m not downvoting or disagreeing with you. I don’t know exactly the exploit mechanisms in terms of id verification. but the result is very clear from arms length - PO Box addresses for accounts have massively higher rates of fraud.
maybe i've been lied to by hollywood but isn't it rather easy to fake an ID in the US?
LE: according to gemini hydrogen it's not easy to open a PO box using a fake ID.
It’s relatively easy (or was, might not be anymore) to make a fake ID that will fool someone who wants to be fooled, so you can get into a bar when you aren’t 21. All the doorman needs is plausible deniability - they showed me an ID, it said they were 21, I let them in.
An ID that will stand up to scrutiny by someone who really cares is not easy to fake. And an actual US Postal Service employee cares.
What's frustrating is that my VoIP number gives me powerful anti-spam tools - that's why I'm reluctant to get rid of it and start giving out my actual cell#!
Pretty much the entire world is VOIP now.
Yes, but in terms of classifying a number, it means something other than "the voice is carried by IP packets at some point in the signal chain"
You missed the part where I said "everyone who doesn't use the plan".
Facial recognition on everyone (something of dubious long-term security value given AI image generation) punishes people who don't use VOIP as well.
Also? Doesn't Google have an API you can query for phone number reputation that gives more fidelity on what is or isn't a trustworthy phone number beyond "VOIP bad"?
> massive fraud correlation
Don't care. There the only way you can keep spam away from you. Everyone tries to collect your phone number and force you into their marketing spam.
You pull that crap and block voip numbers, I am no longer a customer of yours.
You say it as if it’s some sort of new information, but it’s not. Everything in life is a trade-off. I and many others would happily make that trade. Everyone that has done this has made the tradeoff. Not all business is worth pursuing.
That’s fine and that’s your choice. However it’s such a small percentage of legitimate customers that want to use voip, that it’s not worth the fraud loss to support them. Ie, it costs more to serve voip customers than they’re worth to the business. It’s our (and other similar services) choice to serve you too.
Fraud is a fact of life. Credit cards openly encourage fraud and try to mop up the mess after the fact; why can't we apply this to other aspects of life?
? What benefit does a credit card company have to encourage fraud? They're the ones that will be paying out after the fact.
Perhaps a better way of seeing it is: They've found the balance between security and ease-of-use that maximizes revenue for the current point in time.
They could lock it down to requiring TFA + pre-authentication over a phone for every transaction etc etc etc, but the inconvenience to the vendor & customer, and cost to retrofit are probably huge. If it costs $1B to implement a technology that reduces fraud by $500M/yr, and transactions drop by $600M/yr due to the inconvenience, it's probably not worth it.
I'm 100% sure they must have huge fraud / tech departments keeping an eye on emerging fraud methods, counter-measures, etc. I would also bet they work with hardware vendors such as ingenico to keep rolling out new generations of countermeasures at hardware levels, so that when they have enough market penetration, they can start going from "optional" to "mandatory".
Usually fraud is paid for by the merchant. In fact, due to the various fees for everything from 3d secure to charge backs, fraud can be a profit center for the cards and banks (as long as it's not so much fraud the merchant can't pay)
> What benefit does a credit card company have to encourage fraud?
Lesser friction to use credit. Basic security has been an afterthought the entire time. Anyone with your card details can freely use it. Our payments system is a complete joke.
> They could lock it down to requiring TFA + pre-authentication over a phone for every transaction etc etc etc, but the inconvenience to the vendor & customer, and cost to retrofit are probably huge
Yes, security is inconvenient. But they don't even care about trying to come off as securing your money to begin with. There is simply no pro-human option available in the american markets.
I do not clearly understand all that you are implying, but it is a much better framework to state:
-- all of the systems we would be required to use MUST be sensible (acceptable, non-absurd).
that's because by implementing 3d secure too much they lose out on sales and impulse buys, making them less money. the gov has no incentive for this, clearly you have no idea what you're talking about
I've had a bank account for about a decade which forced me to add a phone number. A year or two ago, they insisted on "re-verifying" and then said the current number was invalid for whatever reason, which I assume means I don't have it registered as a postpaid number or have opted out of some data brokers. They still insist on sending 2fa codes to it though. I'm tired of getting stuck with paid, invasive, less convenient, less secure 2fa
Walmart deleted the house phone number I had and told me it was invalid. In actuality it is a home VoIP number that my wife also uses for her separate account and Walmart has decided that although multiple Walmart accounts are allowed per addresses a phone number can only be associated with one of them.
Since I did not desire any interaction with walmart on my cell phone I created a google voice number and gave them that instead which they bizarrely accepted. Then a month later they'd automatically updated the field to have my cell number, probably purchased from my credit card company or whoever!
Oh wow that's pretty bad. Is it possible you or your wife bought something in store and gave them the number, linking it by card number? I've had something similar happen where I bought an item in store, without giving them any extra info, and they sent an email receipt to the online account I had, which I'd most likely used the same card to buy online with before.
Go to your bank branch and say you don't have a phone
And I think some platforms don’t even send SMS login codes to VOYP numbers
No, it’s because it’s a valid and useful fraud signal. It’s just one that has downsides that you personally do not like / are affected by. No model is perfect but some are useful. I assure you that this one is. It’s not for me to say whether or not it’s OK for governments (or the quasi-government entities that a government forces its people to interact with) to use signals that have this particular sort of false positive profile, but you’re being baselessly conspiratorial.
Lots of things are "fraud signals" which are actually just intentional class boundaries.
Your government can use Signal to organize bombings in Yemen, but if you use Signal, you're a potential terrorist.
Sure, a phone plan can be a fraud signal, and that fraud signal will be used as part of a modern digital redlining campaign, denying or restricting access to American citizens who either were born into poverty, value their privacy against the State, or both. It doesn't matter if fraudsters actually fit the profile, but the State appreciates hiding behind the plausible deniability of statistics.
If you use Google Voice because you are an expat (not sure if you are, just wanted to let you and anybody else in this position know about this), Tello is a US carrier that is $5 a month for a texting/calls no data plan, and does wifi calling and shared data calling over your local sim in whatever country you are in. The shared data calling is a bit of a pain to get working the first time, but once I got it set up, it works so well I can even call people on my US number while driving.
Tello looks like a normal US cell number to every government and two factor system, and works as a normal US sim when you are in the US. They also do not cut off your plan if you spend too long outside the US (unlike every other carrier I am familiar with).
Google Voice is the main alternative that people use, but 10-20% of SMS two factor systems do not work with it, mostly financial and government institutions.
The issue with paying money for something like this is that retaining the line - i.e. your ability to prove your identity and merely function in the economy/society - becomes dependent on this payment being made and received on time, successfully. Should anything get in the way of that, your digital life becomes at risk. That is not a great tradeoff.
Doesn't that describe 99% of SMS plans people use for 2FA?
If I stop being able to pay $5 USD a month from any Visa or Mastercard or future standard American payment system (and they will notify me if it declines), I have bigger problems in my life than my 2FA.
It's a problem for all SMS 2FA, yes.
I had this problem when moving to US from Canada. Fortunately I had the foresight to transfer my Canadian number to voip.ms instead of giving it up entirely. Saved my butt a few times.
[dead]
With a free service, retaining the line becomes dependent on the provider continuing to offer this free service, and their whims in deciding whether to continue providing it to you. There's no free lunch.
Sounds like the same thing as VPS providers that try to get themselves misclassified as residential networks. Problem is eventually the classification gets corrected.
It is a normal sim from a real carrier that takes a sim slot in a phone and does wifi calling when roaming, like many other carriers offer. It's just that this one doesn't cut your plan off once you've spent 6 months outside the US (you have to have US billing and activate it in the US).
This sounds great, unfortunately it looks like you have to be in the US to activate this.
>10-20% of SMS two factor systems do not work with it, mostly financial and government institutions.
And my local pub trivia company, and any radio promotions, and my vet's bespoke scheduling system, and my insurance agent's mandated client portal, and....
Let's face it, real world doesn't tolerate fake numbers regardless of their reasoning.
Is your cell phone a smartphone or a dumbphone? The person I was talking about is a retiree who uses a dumbphone that has large buttons, and nothing else. They don't have a web cam and are not tech savvy, so it seems like they are stuck. Treasury Direct and other agencies that rely only on ID.me really forgot that people like them still exist!
I'd suggest going to a bank, see if they can help. It's been many many years but that's where you used to go to buy savings bonds.
https://finbarrow.com/savings/treasurydirect-id-me-required-... contains a helpful matrix of what forms and where you need to go under the "The paper route: which forms still work" heading.
You can redeem paper bonds at some banks. You can’t buy them at banks anymore and they can’t help redeem electronic bonds.
Login.gov offers in person verification at post offices.
Cunningham's Law saves the day. Thanks!
> login.gov, on the other hand, didn't offer any alternatives
Untrue unless something has changed recently. That one actually seems reasonable to me. You can create an account in your browser and then verify it in person at your local post office.
I did have trouble with login.gov being broken by my blacklisting of sketchy third party domains. An official government website should _never_ require loading resources from any domain that resides under a commercial tld. If our legislators were even halfway competent they would completely ban such practices. Call it the REAL Network Security act or something.
I have this issue with the California DMV website. I basically have to disable every measure to use it without it silently failing at some step.
Yes!
The verification options depend on the site you’re signing into. Some are willing to pay for the in-person verification service; others, like the IRS, are not.
I got my Google voice number in 2008. As far as I can remember it was not even publicly called Google voice yet. I still have the email which says
> Finally, we want to say thanks for signing up for the GrandCentral beta.
How can my phone number be an indicator of fraud but some number someone paid five bucks for to get an esim is not?
Because a higher percentage of calls from Google Voice are fraud. It's really that simple, they don't care about you, all they care about is how well each available signal correlates with fraud percentage.
>How can my phone number be an indicator of fraud but some number someone paid five bucks for to get an esim is not?
I assume its because these "fraud" indicators come from 15+ years ago before people starting making scam farms racks out of cellphone parts running automated SMS scams.
Well that and now that copper phone lines are dead in most areas they have to suck it up and accept cellphone numbers anyway.
Might be best to move the bonds out of Treasury Direct in that case. It is a hassle, but you can use paper forms. Here is a write-up: https://finbarrow.com/savings/treasurydirect-id-me-required-...
Or in the other direction (easier rather than harder), you can buy treasuries through your broker often with no fee
> I know a person who is in this situation who has bonds in Treasury Direct that they now apparently cannot cash out. It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner.
It is ridiculous that the government is forcing a third-party private vendor like this, but the Treasury Direct language is very clear that it's only your online access that is restricted - your friend can still cash out their bonds.
> If you would like to know more about ID.me or need help, you can visit ID.me’s help center (https://help.id.me/hc/en-us) or TreasuryDirect’s ID.me FAQ page (https://www.treasurydirect.gov/savings-bonds/help-center/faq...).
> If you do not sign up for ID.me, only your online access to your TreasuryDirect account will be restricted. Your account, funds, and investments remain secure. Please visit the FAQ page above, under the section, “Accessing TreasuryDirect After October 28, 2026” for more information on conducting transactions and retrieving tax documents without ID.me
Emphasis not mine.
I don't know how effective it would be, but there is a change.org petition for adding login.gov to Treasury Direct: https://www.change.org/p/modify-the-mandatorytreasurydirect-...
change.org petitions have negative effectiveness. They absolutely never work, and they distract people from things that do work.
What are the things that do work?
Suspecting what might happen, I cashed out my treasuries before they switched to mandatory ID.me. Something about my setup broke its signup process partway through, even after I uploaded all sorts of personal information, and I would have been locked out otherwise.
Have you actually been on the Treasury Direct website and seen how insanely bad it is? The last time I used it was a year ago, but it rivals the New Jersey state tax website as possibly the most insecure, archaic, pre-HTML4 piece of crap I've ever seen. The fact that they recently bolted on ID.me makes me feel no better about whatever they're doing with data storage; these people can't hire someone who knows how to write a POST query. They could literally give any vaguely competent coder a $250k contract and rewrite the thing from scratch and it would probably be more secure than it is.
> Agencies are required to adopt Login.gov on “in-scope public-facing websites” within two years.
I'll just wait until then. Hopefully I don't need to cash out early!
Why did they implement ID.me if login.gov is becoming a mandate?
> Why did they implement ID.me if login.gov is becoming a mandate?
Because the mandate was put in place... ten weeks ago.
The IRS rolled out the ID.me bullshit partway through the Biden admin.
Which makes absolutely no sense as login.gov has been around nearly a decade at this point.
ID.me could meet IRS remote identity proofing requirements Login.gov could not at the time. Higher identity assurance is required due to historical rampant refund fraud, fraud that has cost billions of dollars.
> The government’s in-house digital identity service has not been without its share of controversy. A March 2023 GSA Inspector General report found that agency officials had misled customer agencies by claiming Login.gov met identity assurance level two standards set by NIST when it actually did not. GSA promised later that year to add facial recognition capabilities in order to meet that standard.
https://www.nextgov.com/digital-government/2026/08/white-hou...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49312680
https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/leader-sophisticated...
https://www.justice.gov/archives/tax/stolen-identity-refund-...
That's just a fig leaf to cover up vested interests. You can get a refund without ever presenting any ID if you submit the traditional paper forms by mail. So the IRS could have verified newly created online account by mail if they so chose. Or they could even have had you main in a paper form to create an online account. Instead we got ID.me and poor excuses for why login.gov was insufficient.
Because paper forms are friction and much harder to scale from a refund fraud perspective, as someone who has some context from interviewing with the IRS identity team as part of a US Digital Service interview loop ~10 years ago to combat this fraud.
You can review the GSA Inspector General reports on Login.gov and the deficiencies that led to slower agency uptake, they are public.
https://www.gsaig.gov/content/gsa-misled-customers-logingovs...
https://www.gsaig.gov/sites/default/files/ipa-reports/GSA%20...
> … although GSA has publicly discussed the use of “selfies” as part of an identity- proofing flow, we have made the decision not to use facial recognition, liveness detection, or any other emerging technology in connection with government benefits and services until rigorous review has given us confidence that we can do so equitably and without causing harm to vulnerable populations.
> When we executed our initial agreement with you, we indicated that Login.gov would be able to meet the IAL2 standards found in NIST 800-63-3. Our decision not to use facial recognition technology, however, means that Login.gov identity proofing services do not meet these standards at this time.
That doesn't seem to be a coherent response to what I wrote above. I pointed out that you can today claim your refund via paper forms without ever presenting any ID. So it is inconsistent that I cannot also register via mail the online account for doing same.
The reports are the proverbial fig leaf to which I refer. What happened with ID.me is a textbook example of grift.
IIRC you used to be able to get creds to access your IRS returns by some physical mail process a few years ago. They started preventing access from those accounts though to force ID.me.
If you fill out a paper 1040 form for your 2025 taxes, and you don't put a bank account and routing number to receive the refund, their online documentation says that you must create an account on irs.gov to provide that info and they will no longer send paper checks. In fact for at least one person who could not do those things, they eventually sent a paper check. But there is no form to claim your refund if you have already filed the 1040 form.
> The reports are the proverbial fig leaf to which I refer. What happened with ID.me is a textbook example of grift.
Believe what you want, it was a unilateral decision by a Login.gov representative out of equity concerns that had to be remediated with technology implementation per the Inspector General’s findings. Provide evidence ID.me was a grift, conversely. Without evidence, it’s a grift solely because you believe it is, and not based on any evidence. They were a commercial vendor who could meet the NIST standards required (800-63-3 Digital Identity Guidelines https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/sp/800/63/3/upd2/final), and Login.gov could not because of a willful decision to deceive partner agencies about the capability.
> Our evaluation found GSA misled their customer agencies when GSA failed to communicate Login.gov’s known noncompliance with the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Special Publication (SP) 800-63-3, Digital Identity Guidelines. Notwithstanding GSA officials’ assertions that Login.gov met SP 800-63-3 Identity Assurance Level 2 (IAL2) requirements, Login.gov has never included a physical or biometric comparison for its customer agencies. Further, GSA continued to mislead customer agencies even after GSA suspended efforts to meet SP 800-63-3. GSA knowingly billed IAL2 customer agencies over $10 million for services, including alleged IAL2 services that did not meet IAL2 standards. Furthermore, GSA used misleading language to secure additional funds for Login.gov. Finally, GSA lacked adequate controls over the Login.gov program and allowed it to operate under a hands-off culture. We found that because of its failure to exercise management oversight and internal controls over Login.gov, FAS shares responsibility for the misrepresentations to GSA’s customers.
If you want your nation state identity provider to be taken seriously, it must operate seriously, which it was not doing, based on the IG investigation. It was the grift until adults were installed.
You're describing how grift works. It can't be totally out in the open - it nearly always requires a fig leaf of some sort. This has every appearance of a back room deal and here you are playing dumb demanding exhaustive evidence to believe what's sitting plainly in front of your face.
You've repeatedly failed to address my point about paper forms not requiring ID to use. As such the NIST standard is clearly nothing more than a thin excuse. If I wasn't assuming bad faith I'd say it was an example of an XY problem and that the people involved were simply incompetent. However I don't believe that at all.
If the IRS flags your paper return or refund, you will receive a CP5071 series notice or Letter 5747C and be required to provide identity documents and verification.
https://www.irs.gov/individuals/understanding-your-cp5071-se...
https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/how-does-the-irs...
Indeed, and such processes long predate ID.me or even the internet. What point do you think you are making here?
My point is paper returns and refunds are going away over the long term [1] [2], and Login.gov is here to stay after doing poorly previously (and is required to access your IRS and Social Security accounts). Make the best of it I suppose if allergic to the concept of government digital identity requirements. I have no strong feelings on ID.me, as a Login.gov user. If it sticks around, it is inconsequential to me as a consumer of US gov services. There is no evidence ID.me was a grift, only a vendor who could provide required services Login.gov chose not to provide and lied to their customers about.
[1] https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-access/p6961a_accessible.pdf
[2] https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/modernizing-payments-to-and-fro...
> In accordance with Executive Order 14247, Modernizing Payments To and From America's Bank Account, signed on March 25, 2025, the U.S. Department of the Treasury, in coordination with the Internal Revenue Service and other federal agencies, is advancing the transition to fully electronic federal payments. This policy shift includes phase out of paper tax refund checks beginning Sept. 30, 2025, to the extent permitted by law.
Why do you think he's playing dumb and it isn't an intentional strategy? What normal person is this invested in defending id.me?
I like facts, evidence, and the truth. Other opinions may differ. If surfacing all of the relevant facts is "playing dumb" you might be in the wrong place. Please, prove me wrong with evidence. But conspiracy theories without any evidence is not productive.
I have no connection to ID.me, have submitted PRs to Login.gov and have them accepted to improve user experience, etc. I like government services, delivered efficiently, broadly speaking. I don't like grift and corruption, especially in the context of government procurement, but am not going to call a situation or matter that until there is evidence of it beyond a preponderance of the evidence (ie "Would this accusation hold up in court?").
"If It's Worth Your Time To Lie, It's Worth My Time To Correct It" - https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/if-its-worth-your-time-to-l... - June 11th, 2025
ID.me is/was such a farce when I signed up:
"Scan the front and back of your Driver's License."
[upload scan of front of DL @ 200DPI]
"Unable to find a face in the image you uploaded."
[upload scan of front of DL @ 300DPI]
"Unable to find a face in the image you uploaded."
Huh. Maybe I'll try with a lower resolution.
[upload scan of front of DL @ 72DPI]
"Thank you, now please upload the back of your Driver's License."
Hmm, 72DPI worked for the front, so...
[upload scan of back of DL @ 72DPI]
"Unable to read a barcode in the image you uploaded."
[upload scan of back of DL @ 200DPI]
"Unable to read a barcode in the image you uploaded."
[upload scan of back of DL @ 300DPI]
"Thank you for verifying your Driver's License".
They started using them for the COVID stimulus payments. Those assholes at ID.me denied me because I dared to use a debit card.
id.me is part of the industrial military complez grift.
it's a private company who long ago operated the army "company stores" on remote bases.
then it morphed into id.me, which was the login required for mil and vet benefits. and let me tell you, having a smartphone and doing a little dance on the selfie camera holding your drivers license is less worse then id.me have been before. anyway, it's a way to sell personel data for advertisers under the guise of benefits via commercial ads and coupons. awful gov sanctioned grift.
so yeah, it's in the core of the bipartisan schemes. they probably have both side in their pockets as this is going for a while.
Isn't it always "because someone paid off politicians via kickbacks to install their company as the solution for $$$$$$$$$". It doesn't matter there's an existing service. All that matters is there is $$$$$$$$$ to be made by making a new service and getting the contract to fulfil it.
> It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party
First time?
> It's absolutely nuts that a federal agency partnered with a disreputable third party that operates in this manner
You're talking about the same government that frequently do multi-million deals with companies that the politicians in the government have ownership in? You're surprised they continue with exactly the same playbook, over and over again?
> The federal government says
Yeah, good luck with that. If anything, these last few years should tell you about how little "X says" actually means in practice, if there is no actual practical and concrete mechanism for forcing anything.
It’s wild because the ability to identify your citizens is one of the only core competencies that spans basically every form and manner of governance, from a huge country’s government to city council.
Like virtually every other function of government first requires establishing who someone is and whether they’re a citizen.
It’s shocking to give that up. If ID.me decides tomorrow they don’t actually like the US government (crazy, but crazy happens sometimes), think about how many US systems just stop working because they can’t tell if you are you or even a citizen.
Some marginalized communities don't have smartphones. I'd be scared of the tax man not including us on ID.gov but there's so little money to take because of the dismal poverty.
Oh come on, you’re saying this as if anyone who is working on that website understands what this means, or what id.me does. They ought to have an identity provider. They got a tender. They got an identity provider. People login. They are done.
It's not that they are doing bad things on purpose. It's actually a result of an acute mental condition called Idontcareism. Nobody cares, and nobody looks.
[flagged]
Just a heads up, not sure when this changed, but it looks like you can login to irs.gov using login.gov.
See https://sa.www4.irs.gov/ola
I don’t understand why we need id.me when login.gov exists, is less intrusive to sign up for, and is actually managed by the government. Why do we always need to insert a profit-seeking middleman in citizens’ dealings with the government?
The story I've heard is that the IRS had pretty unusual verification requirements and a tight timeline that login.gov couldn't meet in time given all the other agency wrangling on their plate. ID.me was willing to meet the timeline, to all of our detriment.
The least believable part of this is the government legitimately having a tight timeline for something like this. Just don't do it this year then.
It has the structure of a classic government contractor scam. Have the requirements written in such a way that you're the only one who can currently meet them and include a deadline that prevents anyone else from having enough time to comply.
>Just don't do it this year then
The IRS has been under a massive amount of fraud - something like $116 billion to $304 billion/yr. They are trying to stop that.
Changing login methods has nothing to do with general fraud though, right?
the biggest fraud is the tax evasion by rich and big co
The biggest fraud is the federal reserve inflating the money supply and making ebery single middle and lower income class family have 8-10% less purchasing power every year.
The Fed's inflation target is typically 2%, and the reason it's that rather than zero is that deflation is extremely bad but it's hard to get the number to be exactly what you want, and it's better to target 2% and sometimes get 0.5% than target 0 and sometimes get -1.5%.
Lately they've been targeting 2% and getting more than that, but not on purpose. Getting exactly the number you want is also hard in the other direction.
It also doesn't help that their nominal boss keeps yelling at them to stop raising interest rates, since "lower interest rates" and "print more money" are effectively synonyms.
60% of all dollars in existance have been printed in the last 6 years. If you still have any trust in the Fed and government my only assumption is that you're age 60+ and are living in the boomer world that doesn't have to worry about finances because you bought your house for $10k half a century ago.
> 60% of all dollars in existance have been printed in the last 6 years.
The M1 has increased by ~12% since November of 2020:
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/m1sl
You presumably meant to say 7 years to get that huge COVID spike into your window, but that was this:
https://economics.stackexchange.com/questions/45886/has-ther...
Are they? Seems like doge fired most of the staff responsible for auditing and detecting fraud
The IRS started testing ID.me through a pilot program in 2017 and then used it for some specific programs, then started using it for every new online account in 2021.
That was long before DOGE came in and started wrecking things.
Used to be id.me for a long time. They recently revamped the website to support login.gov and unify auth across government website. (Probably a shout-out to National Design Studio in government website modernization driving it across the finish line.)
[flagged]
[flagged]
We're talking about both, and what the fuck is a TDS?
[flagged]
Because the GOP want to dismantle and privatize the government. See Project 2025.
The IRS started using id.me in the summer of 2021.
Trump 1st admin brought them in towards then end. Biden admin didn’t undo it. Trump 2nd admin made them mandatory.
It sounds like login.gov is the one that was mandated during the second trump term, if I'm following the timeline correctly. That mandate just hasn't taken effect yet?
Looks like it happened well into the biden admin.
https://www.irs.gov/newsroom/new-online-identity-verificatio...
https://krebsonsecurity.com/2022/01/irs-will-soon-require-se...
No, it launched 9 months into the Biden admin (start of November), this is a news release.
Could the administration have canceled the project? Sure. But it was commissioned, approved, and work begun during Trump's first term.
Mandatory? You can use login.gov now.
I’m just having a hard time correlating this to one particular party.
IRS support for login.gov is very new, as in, definitely this year some time, and it wasn’t there the last time I looked at their login options.
About 2 weeks at this point.
Very recent change it looks like
"insert a profit-seeking middleman in citizens’ dealings with the government" is the basic tenet of capitalism.
Not sure where the surprise comes from.
[flagged]
Context? It seems this was started during Biden administration: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/irs-id-me-tax-file-2022/
Context is here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50544461
I'm a bit surprised that login.gov didn't meet the required standards until 2024!
Isn't this a Biden era policy? Trump sucks in many ways, but inept government spans both parties and isn't limited to recent history.
And ironically the push for universal login.gov is coming from the Trump administration:
https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/M-26-1...
It sure is upside down world. Conservatives want a sovereign wealth fund, liberals want government control over industry, and no one pushes for see federal government.
The 2020 Trump administration made the decision and pre-funded the program, i.e. established a blanket purchasing agreement for the services. This essentially started a ball rolling that would have taken effort to reverse.
More detailed timeline:
In January 2020, under the Trump administration, the IRS determined that login.gov didn't meet its identity verification requirements.
In August 2020, still under Trump, the Treasury Department established a blanket purchasing agreement with ID.me. The IRS began ordering services under that agreement in June 2021, during the Biden administration, but the decision and funding had been established under Trump.
The ID.me procurement was done 17 months later, under the Biden administration, using the existing Trump-era purchasing agreement.
By February 2022, still under Biden, there had been criticism of the face recognition requirement, and the IRS announced that it would work towards adopting login.gov.
Login.gov achieved independent certification against the relevant NIST standard in October 2024. Trump took office three months later, and the transition never happened. It's unlikely to be prioritized under the Trump administration.
> inept government spans both parties
This is not ineptness so much as an ideological preference for using private companies to provide public services. This is often heavily influenced by well-funded lobbying.
For example, the 2005 proposal by Rick Santorum, to restrict public access to restrict access public to weather information that's available from commercial weather providers, was heavily lobbied for and funded by Accuweather. Happily, that one didn't become law.
Some that did become law, backed primarily by Republicans, include municipal broadband restrictions and the 2003 legislation for Medicare Part D which favored private insurers over federal price negotiation.
This Pew Research report shows that among supporters of the two parties, there's a strong preference (74%) among Democrats for government-provided services, with Republicans preferring commercial services by comparable margins:
https://www.pewresearch.org/politics/2024/06/24/americans-vi...
Whether that translates to actual policy is subject to all the usual vicissitudes of the political process.
I'd like to solve the puzzle!
This is great news. I had wanted to check something on my irs account, but am unwilling to authenticate to a .gov site with a .me site. (The .gov sites all say not to trust anything that isn't .gov !)
Although downthread it sounds like it won't accept my existing login.gov account, so probably I'll continue to do without irs.gov access.
I had to do additional verification (in that I don’t think it was ever verified to start with) but could use the same login.gov account.
IRS launched with Login.gov about 2 weeks ago. They've been working on integrating with Login.gov for about 5 years and finally pulled the trigger.
This still requires sending your ID and face for additional verification through a third-party [0]. Even if you already have an account. Why the government can’t/won’t verify their own IDs they hand-out boggles the mind.
Login.gov does support verification through the post office for some government organizations. However, this is not supported for the IRS as best I can tell. Login.gov has pretty poor documentation though. Their phone number has no way to get to a human. I submitted a ticket asking but it appears they just closed it out.
Fun note. In-person to verification can’t accept passports. You can’t use a federal identification (passport) at a federal agency (post office) for access to a federal service (ex. SSA).
[0] https://www.socure.com/
And Socure's terms require accepting an arbitration agreement and class action waiver. It's awful that a government-operated login service requires waiving your right to sue a private company.
It's even more absurd than that. You can mail in your tax return as a paper form without any sort of ID. Then the obvious solution for an online account is to verify it by mail. Yet suddenly facial scans are required "for security"?
> Why the government can’t/won’t verify their own IDs they hand-out boggles the mind.
Slow your horses. To answer your question, I for one refuse to get a Real ID drivers license. (I do have a passport, but that's beside the point.)
What does one have to do with the other? They make the damn things but then pawn off verification to sleazy corporations. A standard ID has the same problem as a Real ID in this case.
I didn't mean to excuse ID.me. Just that the question seemed to presume a national ID card, or that it should be trivial for the federal government to verify a state ID[1]. IOW, it presumed something like REAL ID.
[1] At least without a sophisticated system in place with the states that allows verification without just handing over all the data.
I'm curious, what is your main reason for skipping REAL ID?
Principle. I'm not in favor of a ubiquitous national ID that everybody will by necessity need to carry around.
Can you elaborate? First, nobody is required to carry around a driver's license; it's only needed for when you drive. And in the cases where you need to show a government ID, a driver's license (assuming it's a REAL ID) is just as good as a passport. So I don't really understand your position.
ICE has proven people's fears about the Federal government compiling databases and using facial recognition systems with handheld readers and massive surveillance networks so they can sic jack-booted thugs on people. It doesn't matter they were "targeting" illegals, every aspect of the fear was proven out in horrible fidelity, and nobody was able to pump the breaks before scores of people were murdered in cold blood. REAL ID isn't strictly necessary for that to happen, but it certainly helps[1], and it moves us in the wrong direction. There's a similar threat from states, but that's a separate problem and doesn't justify letting the Federal government have its way.
Also, they will make it increasingly difficult to move around without a REAL ID. This year I took a flight and forgot my passport. SFO was okay with me boarding without a REAL ID. But SAN (San Diego) TSA wouldn't let me through security without REAL ID or purchasing a $50 wavier, which I couldn't do because I couldn't access an e-mail account from my phone and I didn't have access to my laptop, so I had to rent a car to drive back, forfeiting my return ticket. But renting a car without a REAL ID is almost certainly on someone's list of things to fix.
[1] That's why they wanted it in the first place, to make it easier for them to hunt down terrorists and make it harder for people to slip under the radar of pervasive surveillance.
Agreed and also it's obvious overreach. State governments already collect and retain more information than necessary for drivers licenses. Why would we want to make things worse?
For international travel I have a passport, for driving my vehicle and purchasing booze I have a not-REAL-ID drivers license. Other than that only the bank gets to see my ID.
This is also mentioned in the linked article.
There's an article? All these years...
For anyone trying to leave TreasuryDirect because of ID.me: (Note the certified letter option in the third paragraph.)
"We will close your account at your request if there are no security holdings, you have no pending purchases, and if there is no tax information for the current year in it. After 24 months with no activities or securities purchased/held within your account the system automatically closes the account. Once the account is closed it cannot be reopened and a new account would need to be established.
To request your account be closed send us an e-mail from within your account, access your TreasuryDirect account and click "Contact Us" located in the upper right-hand corner of your screen.
You may also make your request in a letter with your signature certified by an authorized employee of a bank or credit union.
Please direct written requests to:
Treasury Retail Securities Services
PO Box 9150
Minneapolis MN 55480-9150
Please note, we will never ask for your password by phone, text, or email.
Thank you,
Treasury Services
Toll Free: 844-284-2676
Hours: 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. EST (Mon-Fri)"
Who the hell decides you can close your account only after two years of non use?
> After 24 months with no activities or securities purchased/held within your account the system automatically closes the account.
(emphasis mine) Looks like it says accounts are automatically closed after two years of non-use, which is different from actively requesting to close an account. (No doubt you'll have to have this argument in your back pocket for dealing with some indolent bureaucrat.)
ID.me, the affiliate marketing company, is doing authentication and identity verification for government? This is going to end poorly.
For the U.S. government, using a foreign nation's TLD.
Exactly. The first time I’ve heard of it I almost thought this is phishing.
To be fair, the U.S. owns that TLD.
5/5 - my account is now locked.
The Treasury Direct switch is a joke. I sold all my bonds (most with a penalty) before the change just to avoid ID.me.
Totally ridiculous that in order to access your savings bonds, you have to provide a private, for profit company your sensitive personal and biometric information, that they will turn around and monetize through spam and god knows what else.
The US gov (OPM) lost my biometric data, fingerprints, blood tests, background check info for security clearance, and even all 3 of my underage children's social security numbers, as well as mine and my wife's back in 2013.
I'm kind of over losing data at this point.
They didn't lose it ... China just hoovered it up :-/
For most of us that's just called a bank.
I'm in nearly the same boat as you. I have 10-year bonds with ~6 years left.
I, however, did not sell them. But I refuse to sign up for id.me. I'm in a wait-and-hope stage that HOPEFULLY some future admin will roll back some of the corruption and reinstate login.gov.
And if they don't, in six years, I'll find some way to be very annoying about it. Not that it'll do any good, but at least I'll feel better about it.
They can perform account operations via paper correspondence, they advised that there is currently about a 10 month delay.
I'd be surprised, personally. ID.me has been popular for years with places that wanted something more than just user/pass. E.g. military veteran status, to use something I'm familiar with. I don't see it getting tossed aside in the foreseeable future for login.gov.
https://www.nextgov.com/digital-government/2026/08/white-hou...
https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/M-26-1...
https://www.gsa.gov/about-gsa/newsroom/news-releases/gsa-app...
Yeah, they also do first responder status and other demographics (there are a few companies online that will offer discounts).
I did this too.
I never got the appeal of Treasury Direct. I already have a brokerage account; just buy treasury bills and bonds from the brokerage account. Sure it’s a little bit more complicated than buying an ETF or mutual fund, but it is like an extra five clicks. It’s the same bonds. I don’t need a new login for my bonds.
> I never got the appeal of Treasury Direct.
One can’t buy i Bonds anywhere but TreasuryDirect.
Which is probably minimal appeal at this point. I bought them for a couple of years when inflation was going a bit crazy. I've thought of cleaning out my account but given the annual contribution limit, I should probably keep what I have for whatever tiny diversification it gives me even if I don't make further contributions.
May I ask what the penalty was?
3 months interest on I-bonds less than 5 years old.
good for you. that's one freedom worth buying. though you'd be surprised how many people are obligated to suffer id.me just to exist
Ex-pat here. Authenticating to ID.ME from Europe was interesting. After some online prep I made an appointment for a video check where I spoke to a rep and showed my ID cards.
The video quality was only so-so and I had a suspicion that the rep was AI-generated... but I did not dare voice this.
ID.me was the only SSO service my mother could actually use, because she has a prepaid cell and VOIP for household phone, both of which login.gov rejects on principle.
How can they know if your cell phone is a monthly plan or prepaid?
login.gov's privacy act statement says mobile carriers may provide customer type and billing type, as well as subscriber name and address, network, account status and imsi and imei. https://www.login.gov/policy/our-privacy-act-statement/
That's pretty wild because I don't remember consenting to my phone company handing out that information to anyone ever. Do they only do this for the US federal government or are they also illicitly sharing my personal data with BigTech when I "verify" an account via SMS?
I hate to tell you, but your cell phone company sells incredibly detailed information about you to basically anyone who asks (pays a small fee through a broker). You would be shocked what I can know about you for $0.10 and your phone number. Consent or no.
Where can I pay my phone company $0.10 to learn what they sell about me?
Sorry for the late reply. You can’t, they sell it to brokers and then 3rd parties offer b2b services with the data. Obstinately for phone number ownership reasons, but I’m sure for all kinds of other reasons.
I worked in an sms heavy tech company, in about 2018 one of these vendors pitched us with a demo for phone ownership verification. I was horrified what it returned. Full demographic and household demographic info and pii for anyone that had owned that number or was in the address that that number had ever belonged to. Incomes, all kinds of stuff. On any number you wanted to input. There’s a reason these companies operate quietly as needtoknow in the b2b space and don’t have public webpages showing what they offer. People would be horrified.
Major carriers let you download a report of personal data they collect, and categories of third parties they share it with. Smaller carriers... I wouldn't bet on it.
- T-Mobile: Submit a request through the T-Mobile Privacy Center (https://www.t-mobile.com/privacy-center/education/about-pers...)
- Verizon: Log into your account and navigate to the Verizon Privacy Dashboard (https://www.verizon.com/privacy/) to access your data report and turn off "Custom Experience" and "Business & Marketing Insights"
- AT&T: Visit the AT&T Privacy Center (https://about.att.com/csr/home/privacy.html) to request your data file and opt out of "Personalized Plus" and data sharing
There are hundreds of data brokers with your data. Either pay for a data-scrubbing service, or search one of them. (https://www.cloaked.com/post/who-is-selling-your-personal-da...)
Also tell your representatives to make it illegal to sell your data without an explicit opt-in. You can erase the data from a data broker, but they'll just buy it again.
It’s almost a certainty they’ll sell it to anyone willing to pay. I’m sure it’s on the fine print.
Some video games require phone verification to prevent cheating and they stopped accepting postpaid numbers. So it's safe to assume it's available to every bum on earth that can rub two pennies together.
You meant prepaid numbers?
Did you read everything you agreed to when you signed up for your phone service? You probably did consent to exactly that.
Phone companies register if your number is part of a long-term contract. Anyone can pay to look that up in a database. If you're not part of a long-term contract, you're "high-risk", and thus your number gets rejected. So you're forced to pay for the phone company's "low-risk", more expensive, contract, to get a number that is "acceptable".
Just another scam in the land of scams.
Welcome to America! Where all your data is available for a price!
https://consumercal.org/about-cfc/cfc-education-foundation/y...
https://theworknumber.com/
https://www.cardfellow.com/blog/level-3-credit-card-processi...
I had to use this horrible website to retrieve my Identity Protection PIN from the IRS website in order to file my taxes. Their automated system didn't work and I had to wait days to get on a video call to get verified. I never saw any option for login.gov; my only option was to use this private service with a domain name based in Montenegro. Truly bonkers
Yeah, .me is not a generic TLD, and instead is a ccTLD. The federal government should not be relying on this.
The Montenegran domain name system is controlled by a US company. We all learned this when they suspended t.me (Telegram).
I was completely unable to complete ID.me verification. ID.me can't cope with the fact that the address printed on my ID is one digit different from the one on my utility bills (because logical and physical streetnumbers don't always correspond)...
Just edit your utility bills.
Yes, millions of people should adapt to a software system forced upon them instead of inconveniencing a tech company
[dead]
I've been audited by the IRS almost every year since I was 18 years old. This privacy violation is incredibly horrible but it's not surprising to me. The IRS is a corrupt organization that supports the rich paying no taxes while harassing the common people for nickels and dimes.
The IRS is responsible for enforcing the code, not writing the law.
You need a new accountant if you're getting flagged every year. The IRS is not well known for auditing low-revenue businesses (per 'nickels and dimes').
This is essentially true,
you go from hiding from the IRS hoping you never get an inconvenient bill from them
to collaborating with the IRS with them signing off on how you’re not going to pay them
I’m personally motivated by this arrangement. The IRS is several different business units that don’t know how the other one moves. And the tax code by number (ie. Section 400 for tax deferrals like retirement plans vs Section 500 for tax exempt organizations) is an entirely different universe than the other number. Nobody gets a fully clear picture except you for the arrangement you’ve synthesized for yourself
Add a lawyer to the mix and its impossible for the government to know what your legal strategy was to disagree with it in a court. The expense alone - of finding out or being wrong - is a deterrent, the energy is focused on cheaper defendants that took a tax credit for being poor
A true audit would be rare. This involves interacting with a human Revenue Agent. Some people get a routine computer-generated letter from the IRS (typically "CP 2000" letter) identifying mis-matches with 3rd party reported data. These letters are not considered audits in the traditional sense.
Hate to say it, but if you’re getting audited every year, you’re doing something really really weird on your taxes.
Unless you are 19 I do not believe this at all. I bet the number of yearly repeated audits is extremely low.
Unless you are doing something really dodgy with a whole lot of money...
TreasuryDirect was also switched to ID.me back in October.
Elizabeth Warren did raise why they didn't use Login.gov instead:
- https://www.politico.com/live-updates/2026/10/29/congress/wy...
- https://www.finance.senate.gov/ranking-members-news/wyden-wa...
I'd like to understand why ID.me doesn't let non-government companies use them as an identity provider. I would love, love, LOVE if I could use a social media site which guaranteed that every user was a US citizen or green card holder.
Anonymity has its benefits, and I don't think it should be outlawed for SURE, but I should have the option of being able to use some social media site that any US citizen could participate in and know that everyone else on the site was a US citizen.
> I'd like to understand why ID.me doesn't let non-government companies use them as an identity provider.
They do let non-government companies use them as an identity provider:
https://id.me/enterprise
With that said:
> I would love, love, LOVE if I could use a social media site which guaranteed that every user was a US citizen or green card holder.
I wouldn't assume that they verify or share US immigration status for any of their clientele, governmental or private. Being ID.me-verified says approximately nothing about US immigration status.
If ID.me sees a valid unexpired US passport or green card, then sure, they know the US immigration status which that document indicates. But there are plenty of cases where they don't know that.
If they see a REAL ID-compliant driver license/state ID, they know the person showed verifiable evidence of lawful presence in the US at the time the application was submitted to the state, but not what the corresponding US immigration status was then or what it is now. If they see a Social Security Number, they know the person either has current or past US work authorization or current or past entitlement to a benefit which requires having a Social Security Number, but nothing else about the person's current or former US immigration status.
The other documents ID.me accepts say even less on the topic.
When they see a foreign passport as the primary ID, the person's current US immigration status could range from none at all to US-foreign dual/multiple citizen to anywhere in between. And they also accept non-REAL ID-compliant driver licenses and state IDs, which are perfectly legitimate and valid for most purposes, and those usually don't indicate immigration status either. Yes, undocumented migrants can get them. But so can any other immigration status. My parents have been US citizens their whole lives and only just switched their driver licenses to REAL ID this year, because their US passports served the few purposes for which REAL IDs are required and so they kept deferring the complex procedure of making that switch instead of easily renewing the old type.
Why?
One simple reason could be to have an online forum with almost no bots.
If every account has to be tied to a real person, the cost of obtaining bots accounts will rise exponentially
> If every account has to be tied to a real person, the cost of obtaining bots accounts will rise exponentially
Nope. Dedicated states love building fakes and passing these identity challenges. That doesn't stop the bots. Also, scammers perform these identity validations with vulenerable populations. (They even sign up their victims for KYCed bitcoin accounts)
Well, the examples you provide just show how much the cost is higher to get an account. And over time, id.me could perform additional security measures which increase the cost even further.
To be clear, I don't like that future, but I suspect that some variation of it will be in demand given the amount of bots exponentially rising.
It doesn't stop the original problem, it just makes the scams worse.
Foreign states mint fake documents all the time, scammers force their victims in to lengthy KYC processes and it gives them more leverage to do even more damage. The companies who invest in this crap end up getting a "get out of jail card for" well we implemented something how can we be responsible.
Why what?
Why do you want a guaranteed US-centric social network?
They said US citizen, not US centric. Plenty of sites are already US centric.
> Plenty of sites are already US centric
But not always authentically so. Pretty much every election cycle someone turns up a network of foreign bots engaging in political debate on the various social networks (and not just in the US either - UK and Australia both have had the same issue)
And now you just answered yourself why OP [probably] wants it. For me at least it seemed obvious.
There are less-charitable explanations: the OP could want to explicitly exclude undocumented immigrants (and anyone else without an up-to-date government ID), from their social networks.
Treasury also requires id.me login now. Absolute nonsense.
I wasn't aware until just now that id.me is not a government-provided service!
What a bewildering state of affairs; it looks like SSA and IRS both allow login.gov (which if I had seen it when I signed in initially I certainly would have used).
Is there a way to migrate off of id.me and use login.gov instead?
For both SSA and IRS you can simply select Login.gov for login and it you will be sent to login.gov where it will ask of you want to link you {SSA|IRS} account.
Say yes and it will go through the verification procedure. When that finishes you will then be able to use Login.gov for login.
Your ID.me login will still work, so if you don't want to keep it as a back up I believe you can login to your ID.me account and somewhere in the settings you can tell it to unlink from {SSA|IRS}.
I recently tried this. I did SSA first, then IRS, which is probably not the best order, for reasons I'll describe below.
At some point in the Login.gov verification flow you have a choice between entirely online or taking taking you ID card to a post office. If you do entirely online it goes like this. (I'm doing this from memory so there may be minor errors in this).
• You enter your phone number and they text you a link.
• The link opens an app that takes a photo of the front and back of your ID card, and then takes a selfie.
• Then back in the browser where you started all this they ask for a phone number that is associated with you, and they do some checking to verify that.
NOTE: this very likely will fail if your phone plan is a prepaid plan. It failed for my Verizon Visible number. At that point you can cancel, start over, and opt for going to a post office.
On the post office path you are given a bar code and instructed to the post office you selected, and show them the bar code and your ID card. They scan the bar code and spend a minute or so doing something on their computer. An hour or so later you'll get an email saying you have successfully verified your ID with {SSA|IRS}.
NOTE: if you end up having to do the post office approach because of a prepaid phone, the good news is that the this will be remembered and in future verifications it should work with the online path.
When I then did the IRS it was the same as above except online verification worked with my prepaid Verizon Visible number.
After all this I then tried it at Medicare.gov. With that when Medicare.gov sent me to Login.gov and it asked if I wanted to link my Medicare account and I said yes--it redirected back to Medicare.gov and I was logged in.
So how come I had to do separate verifications for SSA and IRS and then no more verification for Medicare.gov?
From what I've found out since, apparently a good mental model for how this works is that when it has you verify something that sets a flag on your account that says you've passed that verification and when. When you try to link an account at an agency it knows what flags the agency requires. If there are any the agency requires that you do not have you have to verify those.
The agency can require that certain flags be new. If you already have that flag it will be reverified.
IRS requires the ID and selfie uploads to be new, so I had to do them again even though I already had those flags from the SSA verification. Medicare.gov does not require anything to be new and only requires a subset of the flags SSA and IRS require, so I wasn't asked to do anything when linking that.
Hence, if you do IRS first, then SSA should be a lot simpler because all the flags SSA requires should be there and SSA does not require them to be new.
Not for TreasuryDirect, currently.
I went into TreasuryDirect, redeemed all my I-bonds, and cancelled all my reinvestments on everything else right before this went into effect. Luckily I mostly had short-term notes, so they'll be back in my accounts in a few months. I'm sure it's just a drop in the bucket - all the "real money" holders will go through whatever dance the fed says - but is this really what we should be doing as interest rates rise to a 20 year high?
The whole point of using TreasuryDirect was to avoid counterparty risk with a private company by going directly to the treasury. If I now need id.me approval to access my funds, there's no point for me. I might as well buy treasuries through a broker instead, with all the extra benefits that brings.
They went with an outside provider instead of just extending the sam.gov ID system? Why?
Even if you choose the login.gov option it forces you to accept a _different_ third party terms for identity verification.
I don’t bother calling my reps about many things, but I have called several times about this one. It’s insane that I need to hand over this amount of PII to a private company to log in to the fucking IRS.
Same. I even wrote a letter. More people should do this.
At one point when I did this I got an instruction that was, not verbatim, but no more detailed than: "Go on your phone and download the ID.me app." Putting aside the absurdity of needing to go on my phone, it wasn't a QR code to scan with a link, or some website to go to that links to the right app, just throwing me out there on my own like that. I know enough to feel red flags, and to go to the Google Play store and carefully check the provenance of what I find in the search results there, but they're gonna have normies doing a web search for "ID.me app" and tapping the first ad in the results.
So I was confused.
Just opened VA.gov, tried to login with id.me as one does, and it tried to get me to affirm this crap.
Cool, going to the post office tomorrow and setting up my login.gov account. Thanks for posting this OP
PS - post office cuz you can verify ID there without doing it with Socure the online service used to confirm identity and crap.
Post office experience is a breeze, have done it to test it. Should just need to show the barcode provided by login.gov to the clerk and an acceptable form of ID specified.
Needing to validate identity through a third party to interact with government resources is outrageous.
is this what they meant by SaaS is the future?
Isn't it just ordinary government contracting?
This is why, every year, I print out a huge stack of paper tax forms and mail em.
I'd love it if they'd fix this.
Man i really want these people running my health insurance
It seems a little crazy that the government would put up roadblocks to accessing bonds people bought.
Our government has a debt problem and interest rates on bonds are comparatively high, you'd think they want it to be as easy as possible for the public to buy up debt and help fund our deficit spending.
On the other hand, if it has a greater effect on stopping regular people from redeeming bonds...
Maybe? I'd assume their concern is more about people selling bonds prior to maturity rather than redeeming.
I couldn't sign into my IRS account without enrolling into ID.me earlier this year when I had to get info on my tax return. I'm talking march of this year.
So many problems here... 1) It is insane that there is a specific carve-out that these terms don't apply to you if you're a government worker. Aka, politician. 2) According to this, the Treasury has so far paid $93M for ID.me, and is contractually on the hook for up to 1 billion. Mind you, that money being spent is the taxpayer dollars of the citizens now being forced to use this service. A service that the government already runs (login.gov) without needing to pay a corporation. 3) There are citizens who bought Treasury products with the expectation that they could cash them out when they needed, without an expectation that they'd be giving implicit consent in the future to any arbitrary legal terms from a for-profit corporation.
Political corruption and corporate exploitation. Just another day in the USA.
Also required for www.treasurydirect.gov now.
Ran into the same thing when I tried to manage treasury bonds id already purchased.
America really is a parody in many ways. Thought Soviet Russia had its hand in people's pockets? In United States, you have to pay Company for right to pay Government! (through 3rd party login vendors and through tax prep software lobbying to prevent simplification of your tax filing)
>you have to pay Company for right to pay Government!
But id.me is free for consumers and you strictly don't have to use tax filing software? It's a hassle, but not exactly required either.
Your comment is being flippant with some pretty serious concerns.
Costs don't always present in dollars at the transaction time. There's downside risk to not being able to log into ID.me / IRS online systems.
(1) ID.me doesn't have a 100% accuracy rate. I remember lots of problems when states used them for welfare benefits.
(2) IIRC it raises the requirements for which devices you must use to login (this is old info, so it may no longer apply).
(3) Paper filing is not nearly as fast as online filing, so it could mean weeks of the government holding onto your money longer than needed.
(4) CPAs can charge a lot more than TurboTax / H&RBlock for the simplest filings. Being stuck with paper as the only option is a financial penalty.
(5) The parent mentioned Intuit lobbying to kill the US government's free IRS website filing. That's is even more work that the average OECD country where the government is responsible for doing your taxes for you, as opposed to the US where the time and cost is a burden on the citizen/worker.
Simple tax filings don’t require H&R Block. I used to file my taxes on paper when I was young and my affairs simple. Most workers need only file a 1040 EZ, which is simple as pie; with capital gains on investments you’ll need a regular 1040, which is also not too difficult. It’s when you’ve got Schedule K partnerships in multiple states that you start to need help on taxes, and at that point you probably need an actual CPA instead of H&R Block. Those low-end tax places are the real financial penalty, not a CPA. They exist only because people are too lazy to fill out a 1040 like we all used to have to do.
> Most workers need only file a 1040 EZ, which is simple as pie
The 1040ez was eliminated in 2018 when the regular 1040 was significantly simplified (like down to 1/3 or 1/4 of its previous length). The 1040 has grown a little since then, but is still shorter than it was before 2018.
>Costs don't always present in dollars at the transaction time.
All the factors you've listed are just generic good governance issues, nothing to do with soviet union/communism vs US/capitalism OP was talking about.
Free for consumers means passed to consumers in an opaque way. There is zero reason for commerce to be involved in paying my taxes, or to be required to intermediate software access to services.
Or you don’t understand how tax reporting works. IRS only needs a form from you. How you fill that form is your business.
Is it just me, or is this system poorly thought out?
Like, let's say somebody manages to create an account in my name on ID.me. What has that proven? It relies on shared secrets known to be leaked, like my SSN and a photo of my license. It relies on additional information it can't possibly use to identify me without millions of false positives/negatives when applied across the country (address, phone number, etc), all of which are available from the same data brokers they're using in the first place (whether the info is correct or not) if they're validating against third-party data sources rather than vibes.
Twitter and Facebook can get away with that kind of nonsense if they want, but as a service securing quite large bond and tax refund accounts I'm pretty sure we want to do better.
how rich people but iBonds? any brokerage is allowed to handle it? does treasury direct accept any of the irs power of attorney (51something) forms?
So americans pay taxes, don't receive healthcare, and have to jump through broken KYC to lick boots? well done.
ID.me is the perfect example of a private contractor currying favors with government officials and stealing some sweet tax dollars.
I just hate their practices.
This is the small government, big contractors world the Republicans want.
No. I don't know anyone at all that likes id.me
This is just corruption.
I think this is a case of the government outsourcing critical functions to private companies, which can be dangerous. ID.me's terms are concerning, especially the arbitration clause. It's worrying that they're handling government verification data. Login.gov seems like a better option, but it's not widely known. I wonder how many people are being locked out of their own money because of this. It's a mess
[flagged]
As sso providers go, I have to say I always found Id.me quite nice to use. It always seems to send the 2fa code faster than other providers, and has so far never caused me problems. I am slightly surprised to see the hate for them in the comments. Aside from being a private company, what is the problem with id.me?