Logitech Harmony IR code online database archive

(github.com)

93 points | by cf100clunk 4 days ago ago

29 comments

  • joshstrange 2 days ago ago

    This is awesome and very timely for me!

    I _love_ my Harmony hub. I have 2 in active use and 3 spare hub+controller and 2 spare controllers. I just purchased the equipment to start recreating a hub (reusing the controller) and it comes early next week.

    I’ve watched this space closely and been willing to pay handsomely for something that replaces the Harmony but nothing exists.

    Before you respond with your favorite universal remote, let me give my requirements:

    - Compatible with Home Assistant

    - No screen on remote

    - Remote lasts 6-12+ months on a single coin cell battery

    - Remote talks over RF/BTLE to the hub, no IR on the remote

    Nothing out there fits the bill. CEC is the closest to being a real replacement but CEC is still iffy, even on new TVs and I have older TVs that still work fine.

    Once I’m able to replace the hub side (and reuse the remote) I’ll look into replacing the remote as well. Or at least coming up with a way to recreate it from scratch so I “own” the whole flow.

    • nerdjon 2 days ago ago

      It does seem like the market for this largely died, and I think smart TV's are likely a big reason for this. Mix in controlling a speaker bar from your TV and how many people now just use just their TV remote?

      Which sucks, I refuse to actually use my "smart" tv as such and I have multiple devices, a receiver, etc connected to my TV. Sure gamers still have a device connected but even then, your not controlling the console with a remote.

      I have been clinging to my harmony hub afraid of when it dies, the battery is already crap and it often doesnt charge on the dock anymore.

      I keep looking for alternatives, it needs to either support HomeKit natively or I can get it to work with HomeKit through HA or HomeBridge. Every time I do it always comes down to SofaBaton but then I look into it and I see so many complaints.

      And it isnt like the Harmony worked particularly well, its slow and janky but it got the job done. that seems to be a frustratingly low bar that the others struggle with. (to be clear, I have not tried the others just going based on what I keep reading every time I look it up).

      Been kinda hoping for some open hardware or something and I could build my own software, but that doesnt seem to really exist either.

      • joshstrange 2 days ago ago

        > the battery is already crap and it often doesnt charge on the dock anymore.

        This is why I hate the remotes with screens on them. They require docks since they drain the battery so fast. Compare that to my ~10 year old N-R0005 which I've put <15 coin batteries into over its life.

        I agree with you, smart TVs (and CEC) helped kill this market. I cannot fathom using my TV's built-in apps or its speakers but to each their own... For myself, I'll keep "owning" the different parts of the TV via other hardware and use it as a dumb screen.

        • nerdjon 2 days ago ago

          > This is why I hate the remotes with screens on them.

          I think when it was new and for the first few years the battery lasted pretty well, but now it feels like if I don't dock it every night (or it doesn't make the connection) it dies after a day or 2.

          I do have to say I have a love hate relationship with the screen, the actual navigation of the screen is horrible but it is really convenient for the other people in my home that it explicitly says what the action is, especially when 3 of them are different game consoles a generic "game" button would not work well.

          • joshstrange 2 days ago ago

            Fair point on the screen helping unfamiliar users. It didn't take much "training" to get everyone to understand what the 3 action buttons (short or long press) mapped to but I understand how a screen makes that "foolproof".

            • smackeyacky a day ago ago

              I hate the idea my ancient Harmony One will die. Too many old devices hooked up to let it go unfortunately. I’m very glad to see somebody harvested the remote data might be worthwhile building a replacement out of a Pi perhaps

    • sleep_debt 2 days ago ago

      The Sofabaton X2 has come the closest for me. A little clunky in areas, but they have an API, uses BLE, works with HA, rechargeable battery. BUT it does have a touch screen...still trying to hack mine to deactivate/lock it.

      • joshstrange 2 days ago ago

        Yeah, Sofabaton has been in my back pocket for "If all my Harmony's stop working" but I really don't want a screen and the charging requirements that come with it.

        I _love_ the Harmony remote. It feels good in the hand, easy to use without looking at it, battery lasts for 6-12+ months, and has held up incredibly well (almost/over? a decade of use).

        • sleep_debt 2 days ago ago

          Yea, it was my last ditch effort for an "out of the box" remote without tinkering more with my Harmony. Again, I don't LOVE it, but it's good and gets me like 80% of what I really want/need.

    • FireBeyond a day ago ago

      Yeah, I was so disappointed at the discontinuation. I went with Sofabaton and my conclusion was "had potential, needs work".

      But when Plex released an Apple TV app, that kinda killed the need for me. There's definitely juggling with CEC, including what HDMI port, eARC needs, etc., settings in configs of all devices in the chain etc. But now I have my Samsung TV, Marantz AV Receiver and Apple TV all driven by CEC. For a bonus, when the Apple TV goes to sleep, it turns off the TV and receiver too, versus before when it'd just switch the TV to a default "no input detected".

      The Harmony did such good duty for a long time for me, with cable, internet radio (remember one of the OG Roku devices, the SoundBridge?), PC, etc., and orchestrating that. Now, just less needed. I have spent a whole host of time with HomeBridge and such to build out my Apple Home setup.

  • willis936 2 days ago ago

    Does this enable unbricking of every harmony remote ever made? I've been waiting for this day.

  • WillAdams 2 days ago ago

    One of my wife's friends had a fairly expansive media/entertainment/gaming setup which had them plugging and unplugging things to get them to work, and when the Logitech Harmony came out, they bought one, and paid for "Geek Squad White Glove" service (or whatever it was called at the time) and a tech came out on a Saturday morning with the box, disconnected _every_ device, and got started.

    Apparently, it took him the entire day, but at the end, everything was connected, every cable was neatly, and where possible, invisibly, run, and all the other remotes were relegated to a drawer, and there was a CD-RW which had the entire configuration backed up, and the one remote controlled _everything_ in a consistent and straight-forward manner.

    I solved my far more modest setup problem by just buying a VCR/DVD combo unit and TV from the same manufacturer.

  • wiether 2 days ago ago

    Interesting!

    I recently revived my Harmony that had some buttons that were less and less responsive thanks to ButtonWorx[1]

    And then I started to think about the software side of things now that I had secured the hardware's future.

    After going through the README and a bit of code, it seems that the project is an alternative to the database behind MyHarmony.com ; to work without Logitech (either because they already stopped supporting the remote or because they'll most likely drop everything sooner than later), an alternative to their software is required.

    I've found a few projects, like Concordance, that seems to try and close this gap, but to this day I haven't found a full 1:1 replacement to MyHarmony.com and the Windows/MacOS app.

    [1]: https://buttonworx.com/logitech/322-464-Logitech_Harmony_650... - Product is great, tutorial video is great and delivery to Europe quite fast

    [2]: https://github.com/jaymzh/concordance

  • cf100clunk 4 days ago ago

    Mad propz to fizi for curating the Harmony IR Remote Control code database!

    https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=fizi

    • fizi 6 hours ago ago

      Awww, shucks

  • dukoid 2 days ago ago

    Kind of related: I recently got a Sofabaton U3 and I am kind of happy with it after I figured out how to avoid on/off state dependencies:

    - Receivers often treat "input select" as "on" (fortunately Denon seems to miss "on" but still has dedicated "off"

    - Similar for Android TV: Just use "home" instead of "power" to avoid the stupid state-dependent power toggle command

    • tyleo 2 days ago ago

      SofaBaton is interesting. They cost a fortune, have terrible software, yet they seem like the only Harmony replacement on the market. I say this as an owner.

      I’ve felt that this space is just waiting to be disrupted.

      I feel like people just want:

      1. an IR blaster

      2. optionally Bluetooth/radio/etc

      3. a nice app they can configure from their phone

      4. a DB of most existing codes

      That’s what I want at least. 3 in particular seems like a major struggle and I don’t think even Harmony did great.

      • joshstrange 2 days ago ago

        The Harmony app was dog shit but, it did work. It was slow and frustrating but of the, quite literally, thousands of hours I've spent with the Harmony remote (N-R0005) I've spent <3hr total in the app. So yes, the app was/is trash but I never had to use it and mostly it was the configuration part that was bad. Using it as a remote wasn't terrible but I only did that a handful of times when I couldn't find the remote.

        SofaBaton is disqualified for me due to its screen. I don't want an LCD screen (or OLED or e-ink) on my remote. I use the remote often without looking at it, the screen is just a power-suck and if they have an LCD 99 times out of 100 they also have wifi (see: power suck). I don't want to think about charging my remote, and with the N-R0005 I never do.

      • gorbiesRedScar a day ago ago

        Have you considered just using a (xaomi) [Qin F22 Pro](https://qinphone.com/products/android12-smartphone-qinf22pro...)

        It's a dumb-ish android phone (can go to android 15(?) with dumberOS) with a keypad and IR blaster.

      • dukoid 2 days ago ago

        I did not find the app too bad -- maybe the star rating adjusted my expectations... :) Ok, it could default to the current device instead to the first when adding stuff and it should save by default... but I have seen worse.. Also perhaps the price for the x3 made the u3 look not that bad?

    • 2 days ago ago
      [deleted]
  • Melatonic 2 days ago ago

    Not the first I've seen and there's a whole group reverse engineering these and looking for help

    More sources always good to have though !

  • 2 days ago ago
    [deleted]
  • tvbusy 2 days ago ago

    Awesome. I'm going to tell AI to lookup the codes from this repo for my ESPHome IR emitter. This is going to save a lot of time.

  • jgalt212 2 days ago ago

    The only multi-device working remote I have right now resembles the Megatron.

    https://peepshow.fandom.com/wiki/The_%22Megatron%22

  • Agataproximadev 2 days ago ago

    [flagged]