My Emacs 31 contributions

(xenodium.com)

120 points | by xenodium 4 days ago ago

29 comments

  • wilkystyle 2 days ago ago

    Xenodium/Álvaro Ramírez is a legend. agent-shell.el is my favorite Agent/ACP interaction layer I've ever used, across any IDE, and I'll shout it out every chance I get.

    • empthought 2 days ago ago

      It's really great and is steadily improving with every release. It could be the biggest "killer app" for Emacs since org-mode.

    • isityettime a day ago ago

      I also love agent-shell. I use it regularly to drive Claude, Codex, and Cursor. I think it's great, and the rate of improvement is also really good. Whatever subscription or client my company is letting me try out on any given week all goes into the same workflow, and it's really nice. It plays nice with Projectile as well, so ever project I have has its own session(s) and Emacs serves as my LLM agent multiplexer. The dedicated compose and viewport buffers are really nice to have because I tend to write long prompts, lol.

      • xenodium a day ago ago

        > I also love agent-shell.

        Great to hear it. Thank you.

        > I use it regularly to drive Claude, Codex, and Cursor.

        I'm thankful for ACP. Had it not been for this protocol, I'm not sure I would have started agent-shell. Having to rebuild the same logic for different providers over and over again feels fairly wasteful (I did that for chatgpt-shell).

        > Whatever subscription or client my company is letting me try out on any given week all goes into the same workflow

        So they happily spend on tokens... Any chance you can get your company to sponsor agent-shell? ;)

    • xenodium a day ago ago

      > agent-shell.el is my favorite Agent/ACP interaction layer I've ever used, across any IDE

      That's lovely to hear. Thank you. I've played fairly little with agents in other IDEs. I basically started agent-shell because I was curious about agents, and wanted to play with them, but didn't want to leave my Emacs comfort zone ;)

    • sourdecor a day ago ago

      Does Claude Code /rc work in agent-shell.el?

      • empthought a day ago ago

        I just checked. You have to invoke it as /remote-control for some reason, but it works.

  • noctuid 2 days ago ago

    > which does feel a bit archaic (download, sign, and return a PDF) and slow (mostly waiting for an email response), though hey, I have nothing but sympathy. Open source is unsustainably tricky. As consumers, we often like free as in freedom and free as in beer, but neither pay the bills. We hope some company steps in to fund these projects, but that rarely happens. As a result, most open source projects are starved (even popular ones), run by volunteers working for free.

    These two are completely unrelated.

    > All that is to say, if the upstream Emacs contribution/onboarding process seems less than ideal, cut it some slack

    At my first job I tried for over a year to get my company to sign. Since then, no job I've interviewed for has been willing to sign the papers or actually signed them regardless of the company size. Too much process that stalled and never completed. It was actually the smaller companies I spoke with that weren't even willing to sign anything regardless of narrow, straightforward, and clearly unrelated to job work it would be. Obviously there are software engineers that are able to get the papers signed, but that's just one small aspect of how ridiculous everything GNU and FSF related is. I can't wait for a proper non-GNU emacs again.

    • NetMageSCW 2 days ago ago

      Why do you need a company to sign them?

      • collinfunk 2 days ago ago

        Software Developers in the US commonly work for hire, so the code they write, even outside of work, may be the property of their employers. This depends a bit on state law.

  • kodoman 2 days ago ago

    Hmm no one has said it yet but thank you, I get a lot of benefit out of your work I love acp.el, when I get a bit more money would love to start sponsoring this sort of stuff because thanks to people like you emacs can use all the modern stuff better then the IDE's. Thanks!

    • xenodium a day ago ago

      Glad to hear you find my work useful! Thank you.

  • emil-lp 2 days ago ago

    > Open source is unsustainably tricky.

    What's that supposed to mean?

    • xenodium 2 days ago ago

      Clumsy wording on my part. I meant open source is hard to sustain: free as in freedom and free as in beer are both lovely, but neither pays the bills for most maintainers (there are exceptions, of course).

  • pnathan 2 days ago ago

    thank you! I use emacs daily!

  • eviks 2 days ago ago

    > All that is to say, if the upstream Emacs contribution/onboarding process seems less than ideal, cut it some slack.

    But it takes more effort from the org to manually review those stupid PDF forms?

    > some took quite a bit of effort to land upstream.

    Entirely due to self-inflicted bureaucracy.

    Given the limited resources of "unsustainably tricky" open source, wouldn't you want the process to be welcoming new contributors instead of pushing them away?

    • empthought 2 days ago ago

      > Entirely due to self-inflicted bureaucracy.

      You might know this, but in case you don't, there is a very specific reason for this. GNU/FSF has an ideological commitment to "copyleft" as a method to ensure software is always distributed with its source code and is freely modifiable.

      The putative enforcement method for "copyleft" requires that copyright documentation and assignments be strictly tracked.

      While you are correct that it is "self-inflicted bureaucracy," I think people will read that with the connotation of "(pointless) self-inflicted bureaucracy," when that is simply not the case. GNU/FSF's Free Software (free-as-in-freedom) project is prone to failing for totally avoidable reasons without this documentation.

      • holgerschurig a day ago ago

        > You might know this, but in case you don't, there is a very specific reason for this

        No, there is no reason. It is just stated, but was never proven.

        I mean, Linus Torvalds also has a "ideological commitment" that the Linux kernel should be GPL so that the source is always available. And he doesn't anyone to sign over the copyright to him. And what's more: the binding force of the GPL was even holding up before courts ... in the Linux kernel case.

        The FSF is almost spamming Mastodon with claims that the copyright transfer is somehow needed. I replied twice to them asking for details. They never came up.

        So all we know: even courts hold the GPL valid, but without a copyright transfer. And we also know that the FSF never actually talks beef, e.g. which copyright infringement case they won because they were the copyright owner.

        So it looks really like a "(pointless) self-inflicted bureaucracy".

        That being said: US style copyright is incompatible with quite a few european countries (which usually don't have an anglo-saxon law/court system). For example, in Germany you have "Urheberrecht". It looks like Copyright, but really isn't. For a start, you can't transfer your "Urheberrecht" itself.

      • eviks a day ago ago

        The statement you quoted was referring to the whole process of elaborate discussion re blocking a useful feature.

        But it is also pointless for your cause: you don't need to assign to track, and you definitely don't need an archaic process of tracking. You know, other copyleft projects exist with a better process. Some of those are even FSF projects

        https://lwn.net/Articles/857791

  • philjackson 2 days ago ago

    When I signed the copyright contract they sent me some stickers, so probably worth it.

    • auslegung 2 days ago ago

      I am a sucker for some good, free stickers. What do the stickers look like?

  • alfiedotwtf 2 days ago ago

    > You see, Emacs has been around for 50 years. Very few software projects get to live this long

    This!

    I think about this often, and yes Emacs is one, and I’d put Debian as a whole on that list too.

    Once Emacs clicks as a philosophy (tl;dr: it’s not just an editor, it’s YOUR editor) it’s a whole new world.

    It’s been interesting lately for me - playing with different harnesses, I’ve found pi.dev to have this same philosophy - the provide you a canvass and you have to find your own paint and brushes to create a masterpiece

    • bluepoint 2 days ago ago

      I tried to get to emacs several times, always got bored after trying to configure it. It takes a huge effort to make it your editor. However the fact that you can run claude inside it and has access to its entire state, can make changes to the environment live is really a game changer. It even converts some textual apps to emacs native stuff and it is mind blowing.

    • spiralpolitik 2 days ago ago

      Emacs is a user-customizable environment with a text editor. At one point you could do everything in Emacs and I frequently did.

      In many ways Emacs was both ahead of its time and continuously behind it. It never quite transitioned to the post-1995 GUI/web based world and held onto too much of the past. The core idea is however timeless and my hope has always been that someone will reinvent it for the 21st century.

      • TFNA a day ago ago

        To claim that Emacs didn't transition to the GUI world is inaccurate. With the transition to modern graphical toolkits it got extensive styling and multilingual support, including BIDI and Harfbuzz-enabled text shaping. Menus were present and powerful already when I started using it in the late 1990s. Image support has been there for long years, and recently there have been strides in canvas with all kinds of whiz-bang graphical stuff.

      • isityettime a day ago ago

        > my hope has always been that someone will reinvent it for the 21st century

        Atom was supposed to be that. In a way, Firefox in the days of XUL was.

        > It never quite transitioned to the post-1995 GUI/web based world

        What do you think it should do in order to do that? What is graphical Emacs missing today, or (worse) what is paradigmatically wrong with it?

  • eggnog92 2 days ago ago

    fantastic!

  • 2 days ago ago
    [deleted]