Thunderbird breaks compatibility with plugins, again and again and again. To the point that most plugin developers have straight up given up on maintaining their plugins, because it’ll only be for Thunderbird to break everything once again.
Every time I do a system update and Thunderbird is in the list of packages, it’s a gamble on whether next time I open it half the plugins I depend on daily have been taken out back and shot.
It’s slow. Sometimes it takes up to three minutes just to open a single email (I timed it). And no, it’s not my mail provider. In the web app and in Claws mail it’s instant every time. Half of the time using Thunderbird is sitting there like a melon watching that stupid little blue bar throb away in the bottom right corner, waiting for something to happen in response to any of the clicks or key presses I did five or ten minutes ago.
And the redesigns. Oh, God, the endless, frivolous redesigns. Each one serving only to move stuff around so we can’t find it, waste more space with needless UI padding and fisher-price rounded edges, make the app actually slower and clunkier with its CPU-hogging animations and multi-layered composited fancy pants shadows (which don’t even work right with most compositors so you get another “ghost shadow” a few pixels round the edge), reshuffle all the UI components so nothing’s where you remember it being for the last however many years… did I already mention that? I guess I’m just too “entitled” (actual real words of a Mozilla rep) to have to re-learn a UI every few months because some designers and marketing idiots are bored and need job security. It’s not like I have anything better to do than gawk at your border-radius-tactic CSS animations. Certainly not anything to the scale of, say, a full-time fucking job that largely consists of reading and responding to emails, something Thunderbird is by this point actively hindering me from doing. And they harp on and on about how “beautiful” it is, as if they’re trying to convince themselves they haven’t wasted everyone’s money.
The last time I opened Thunderbird (and thank God it really was The LAST time) it opened with a full page splash screen - yes, a pop-up ad - asking me to donate! Why? So you can piss about breaking more plugins and shitting up the UI once more? Not a fucking penny until they bring back the proper pre-68 branch. Too late for me, I’ve migrated to Claws Mail and am all the happier for it. Fuck Thunderbird.
I loved the user experience of local mail apps, but multiple devices killed it imo. I used yahoo mail over pop3 and then gmail over imap for a bit but the syncing experience was just too clunky in a lot of small ways and I finally gave up and just use webmail now. I like the mental model of my email sitting in a single place rather than being distributed and having to reconcile itself across places.
A few months ago, I tried to implement the same reference app in Go, Rust and Zig and AI working with Zig was very troublesome, lots of tokens were spent and the result was subpar.
I think it's because Zig source code is scarce in the wild, Zig API is constantly changing and the trainers might not care enough about Zig to source enough samples for training.
And it's here in the comments. The app's page says it's "for Gmail and Fastmail" with no mention of this JMAP.
Edit: Funny, from the comments here I started by assuming JMAP is the common link between gmail and fastmail, when in reality the app supports both google's proprietary protocol and also jmap, which happens to be implemented by fastmail.
For sure, that’s probably a different project. I’ve been wishing for an actually good E-Mail client based on JMAP (I consider that to be instrumental to “actually good”) for a while. I haven’t checked out the landscape since the AI explosion though so I should probably look again.
I learnt of Bulwark recently from another HN post which seems to be surprisingly powerful. It's designed for use with the Stalwart email server, but it runs over JMAP, so it may well be compatible with other email servers. In any case it's the best new webmail client I've seen in recent times.
https://bulwarkmail.org/
Wow, that looks great, thanks for the recommendation!
It’s a bit “traditional” to fit my definition of “actually good”, but it looks very full-featured and polished for what it is (they even have a mobile app!).
What’s really exciting to me is that they built what I considered the missing piece for JMAP adoption: An IMAP translation component! https://github.com/bulwarkmail/legacy-proxy
I will try it, if it supports sending from an alias then it should be a good start, although I am not a fan of labels and prefer folders. Side question, was it opus 5.5 that made/helped make it? I know opus love uses Just compare to others, just curious.
I’ve always resisted a local mail app because Fastmail’s web ui is so good… but this may actually do it.
Might be good to rewrite the readme and replace all the LLM speak. I have no idea what this could possibly mean. Haha
> r replies, over a quote of what you answer.
I like Thunderbird a lot. It's also an RSS reader, Calendar, and address book, and IMO it's quite pretty.
Same. Especially if you switch to Betterbird and use a theme matching the system, like adwaita theme for Gnome.
Thunderbird breaks compatibility with plugins, again and again and again. To the point that most plugin developers have straight up given up on maintaining their plugins, because it’ll only be for Thunderbird to break everything once again.
Every time I do a system update and Thunderbird is in the list of packages, it’s a gamble on whether next time I open it half the plugins I depend on daily have been taken out back and shot.
It’s slow. Sometimes it takes up to three minutes just to open a single email (I timed it). And no, it’s not my mail provider. In the web app and in Claws mail it’s instant every time. Half of the time using Thunderbird is sitting there like a melon watching that stupid little blue bar throb away in the bottom right corner, waiting for something to happen in response to any of the clicks or key presses I did five or ten minutes ago.
And the redesigns. Oh, God, the endless, frivolous redesigns. Each one serving only to move stuff around so we can’t find it, waste more space with needless UI padding and fisher-price rounded edges, make the app actually slower and clunkier with its CPU-hogging animations and multi-layered composited fancy pants shadows (which don’t even work right with most compositors so you get another “ghost shadow” a few pixels round the edge), reshuffle all the UI components so nothing’s where you remember it being for the last however many years… did I already mention that? I guess I’m just too “entitled” (actual real words of a Mozilla rep) to have to re-learn a UI every few months because some designers and marketing idiots are bored and need job security. It’s not like I have anything better to do than gawk at your border-radius-tactic CSS animations. Certainly not anything to the scale of, say, a full-time fucking job that largely consists of reading and responding to emails, something Thunderbird is by this point actively hindering me from doing. And they harp on and on about how “beautiful” it is, as if they’re trying to convince themselves they haven’t wasted everyone’s money.
The last time I opened Thunderbird (and thank God it really was The LAST time) it opened with a full page splash screen - yes, a pop-up ad - asking me to donate! Why? So you can piss about breaking more plugins and shitting up the UI once more? Not a fucking penny until they bring back the proper pre-68 branch. Too late for me, I’ve migrated to Claws Mail and am all the happier for it. Fuck Thunderbird.
I loved the user experience of local mail apps, but multiple devices killed it imo. I used yahoo mail over pop3 and then gmail over imap for a bit but the syncing experience was just too clunky in a lot of small ways and I finally gave up and just use webmail now. I like the mental model of my email sitting in a single place rather than being distributed and having to reconcile itself across places.
Me too - though I switched to the Fastmail app a while ago. The one thing that it's missing is a back / forward stack.
Confusing when there's another email product out there called Parcel.
https://parcel.io/
True but I think that project is archived on GitHub as of October this year. It looks like they took the repo down as well
It's nice seeing AI being used to write Zig.
A few months ago, I tried to implement the same reference app in Go, Rust and Zig and AI working with Zig was very troublesome, lots of tokens were spent and the result was subpar.
I think it's because Zig source code is scarce in the wild, Zig API is constantly changing and the trainers might not care enough about Zig to source enough samples for training.
> A mail client for Gmail and Fastmail on the Linux desktop
Huh. It's not a mail client. It's a gmail and fastmail client.
> A bicycle for riding on roads.
Huh... it's not a bicycle, it's a road rider.
Bad analogy. The correct analogy would be that it's a road rider that only lets you ride on specific streets.
This project supports JMAP, which is an open protocol. So it's more like, only lets you ride on paved streets.
Ah ok, I went off the people saying it was only Gmail and fastmail.
Well, to be fair, it still may be, haha. Not sure how much support JMAP actually has out there.
First time I hear of it :)
And it's here in the comments. The app's page says it's "for Gmail and Fastmail" with no mention of this JMAP.
Edit: Funny, from the comments here I started by assuming JMAP is the common link between gmail and fastmail, when in reality the app supports both google's proprietary protocol and also jmap, which happens to be implemented by fastmail.
Well, yes. With a bicycle you can ride pretty much anywhere. A bicycle restricted to roads is objectively worse.
> > A bicycle for riding on roads.
On two particular roads and nowhere else. Yes one of them is very popular, but still...
Well, look at me wishing it was web-based.
For sure, that’s probably a different project. I’ve been wishing for an actually good E-Mail client based on JMAP (I consider that to be instrumental to “actually good”) for a while. I haven’t checked out the landscape since the AI explosion though so I should probably look again.
I learnt of Bulwark recently from another HN post which seems to be surprisingly powerful. It's designed for use with the Stalwart email server, but it runs over JMAP, so it may well be compatible with other email servers. In any case it's the best new webmail client I've seen in recent times. https://bulwarkmail.org/
Wow, that looks great, thanks for the recommendation!
It’s a bit “traditional” to fit my definition of “actually good”, but it looks very full-featured and polished for what it is (they even have a mobile app!).
What’s really exciting to me is that they built what I considered the missing piece for JMAP adoption: An IMAP translation component! https://github.com/bulwarkmail/legacy-proxy
Cool stuff!
I will try it, if it supports sending from an alias then it should be a good start, although I am not a fan of labels and prefer folders. Side question, was it opus 5.5 that made/helped make it? I know opus love uses Just compare to others, just curious.