Show HN: Shoehorn – Quantize any model down to run on your machine

(notactuallytreyanastasio.github.io)

67 points | by rhgraysonii 3 days ago ago

17 comments

  • puttycat an hour ago ago

    This is really impressive. Can you say a bit about the underlying process? I'm guessing this is post-training qantization? Isn't PTQ also resource-intensive? (Ie might not work on any machine)

  • sscarduzio 2 hours ago ago

    The project name is perfect!

  • hmokiguess 3 days ago ago
    • rhgraysonii 3 days ago ago

      LLMFit tells you what can run on something. I built something quite similar to their search into Shoehorn now.

  • jedbrooke 3 hours ago ago

    I gotta laugh at some of the models it suggests, for example:

    > AnkitAI/Parable-Qwen3-4B-Claude-Fable-5-GGUF

    you’re telling me you managed to fit Fable 5 into just 4B?

    • chompychop 3 hours ago ago

      I gotta laugh at your thought process: knowing Fable 5 is a large frontier model, you're telling me that the first thing that came to your mind on seeing that model name is that it's a quantized version of Fable? As opposed to a distillation/fine-tuning on Fable responses?

      • metalliqaz an hour ago ago

        Well to be fair here... the title of this post doesn't mention fine tuning, it mentions quantization.

      • unrented7977 2 hours ago ago

        Don't make fun of people you think are ignorant, it's a pretty shitty look

        • chompychop 2 hours ago ago

          Well, then don't get all snarky and dismissive of things you might not be knowledgeable about ("you" here referring to OP).

  • akshay_akula 2 days ago ago

    This is interesting. I wonder how it could work with something like https://github.com/JustVugg/colibri.

  • mbuchel-hn 3 days ago ago

    does this work similar to airllm? i am wondering how it would handle something like quantizing kimi k3 on a budget of 8 gbs, or is that something you are not attempting to solve yet?

    • rhgraysonii 3 days ago ago

      Yes that is exactly what this does.

      • kennywinker 3 days ago ago

        Could you explain what happens when you try to shoehorn a 2.4T parameter model into a 24gb m4 mac?

        • metalliqaz an hour ago ago

          extreme divergence would be my guess

        • akshay_akula 2 days ago ago

          Wondering the same thing but for 48gb M5 Max.

  • jaylane 3 days ago ago

    tried it out but based on the model sizing result i got i got an insufficient memory error when the server started running

    • rhgraysonii 3 days ago ago

      If you could post an issue if you still have the error around that would be awesome.