Show HN: Scroll Wikipedia like TikTok

(quack.sdan.io)

313 points | by sdan a day ago ago

81 comments

  • thiht 10 hours ago ago

    I thought the scroll didn’t work at first, apparently only the bottom of the screen is scrollable. I see other comments talking about a voice, I don’t have it, just the music? Also the content is really irrelevant and uninteresting (I’m assuming it uses a random article? It should aim for the most popular instead), it really needs some curation.

    The subtitles are also hard to read, they should be displayed sentence by sentence, not word by word.

    IMO you didn’t capture what makes some interesting content work on TikTok. The scientific content on TikTok doesn’t have the brainrot music, it’s just interesting because of the short format. It looks to me like a clone of TikTok made by someone who hates TikTok and built it out of assumptions on what TikTok is.

    Honestly interesting Wikipedia articles summarized as TikTok content is a killer idea, but the implementation is not there yet

    • looofooo0 6 hours ago ago

      Graph structure of wiki could be exploited for user specific content.

    • saltwatercowboy 10 hours ago ago

      I think you are taking this more seriously than the creator. It's just a bit of fun.

      • thiht 8 hours ago ago

        Yeah because I think it’s a seriously good idea. Making knowledge and science somewhat addictive is a cool goal

        I could see myself using that

  • jaredsohn 21 hours ago ago

    Next step is allow viewing TikTok like wikipedia. Take a bunch of popular tiktok posts, use an LLM to describe what's happening via text/screenshots (with references to memes, etc), and link them to other relevant tiktoks.

    Some meme sites might be somewhat similar to this.

    • lysp 16 hours ago ago

      > Next step is allow viewing TikTok like wikipedia

      I tried that and this is what I got:

      Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nullam tincidunt at dui vel suscipit. Donec finibus viverra tempus. Ut ut tellus ac mi ultricies fermentum a quis nulla. Vivamus urna mi, laoreet ac purus sed, ultricies tincidunt nisi. Quisque vulputate massa nec hendrerit consequat. Suspendisse potenti. Phasellus dapibus suscipit vulputate. Suspendisse id semper turpis, sit amet rhoncus nisl. Aenean auctor purus orci, eget ullamcorper lorem volutpat sit amet.

    • NoteyComplexity 17 hours ago ago

      Instead of LLM and just like Wikipedia, there should be users to submit the descriptions of the videos, and see people fighting for getting the most “correct” description.

      It will be hilarious to see what people will come up with when they see brain rot content.

    • nephihaha 9 hours ago ago

      Allow TikTok to be run like Wikipedia... So that people with no interest or knowledge of a particular subject can go round deleting said content, or blocking every shared IP from uploading content while saying anyone can edit it.

      • nolok 7 hours ago ago

        That's a very wrong view of how Wikipedia works, and frankly vastly I prefer its limited but generalized gatekeeping than "everybody is allowed to lie and bullshit and as long as it makes engagement your feed is going to be filled with it" the TikTok way.

        • nephihaha 5 hours ago ago

          I have at least twenty years of experience of Wikipedia, and it is exactly how it works much of the time. I lost count of the occasions when people with no knowledge of a particular subject kept trying to delete articles on it. Then there were the continuously changing rules, jargon and oligarchical structures...

          Some subject areas have much better coverage than others: linguistics is much better dealt with than sport for example.

          Nowadays I rarely edit Wikipedia, because they block most shared IPs. I used a named account for at least ten years and it was counterproductive.

    • rhplus 7 hours ago ago

      TikTok like Wikipedia, huh? So we’d finally get to see how much of the recommendation algorithm was edited by IP addresses from US gov, Chinese gov and Russian bots?

    • baby 15 hours ago ago

      There's already memepedia

  • mandeepj an hour ago ago

    > fully generative UIs where the HTML/Canvas are generated just-in-time

    Why? The UI is a template and the core structure never changes, in the context of TikTok’s feed, so what’s the benefit you are trying to reap by dynamically generating the UI?

  • xnx a day ago ago
    • SirFatty a day ago ago

      "This was inspired by Wikitok, a VSCode Extension I made around brainrot, and another fully generative UI site I made."

      • mellosouls a day ago ago

        I also thought immediately of WikiTok and was confused by this exchange and the grammar in the quote here; I thought they were claiming to have made a VSCode extension called Wikitok. I understand now!

      • xnx a day ago ago

        I saw that but got the submitter and commenter names mixed up, so I didn't realize it was the same person.

      • aizk a day ago ago

        :)

  • cons0le a day ago ago

    This is amazing! I think this could actually catch on!

    Plz give an easy way to follow some tags so it's not showing me football stuff. If it was just topics I was interested in, I could scroll this for hours.

  • -i 12 hours ago ago

    747.run is a realtime infinite Ai wikipedia, every word is a link to a unique article based on the word in the URL, Ai frequently checks all URL's and writes a new article based on the word you click.

    You can also write articles and all your words become links, use the website address bar to type any word after 747.run/ or type 747.run/ behind any domain to generate unique articles based on domain.

    Have a group chat with unlimited people and Ai, share any link to chat with anyone, press space to chat with the Ai, have an Ai chatbot on your website or chat with users privately by embedding it on your website with iFrame (set BG color or leave it transparent)

    The Ai sometimes drifts & hallucinates.

  • recallingmemory a day ago ago

    Neat idea, and love the Undertale menu mp3: https://brainrot-vscode-ext.sdan.io/quack/music/undertale-me...

  • asciii 19 hours ago ago

    This is so awesome - i wish I could modify that annoying voice :)

  • personjerry a day ago ago

    The animations + audio are great. I feel like these meaningfully differentiate from some other similar projects. There's a lot of potential here.

  • baby 15 hours ago ago

    Wow this is so freaking awesome! I guess the pages I ended up scrolling on weren't too interesting though, how do you figure out what stories to create/show?

    • sdan 13 hours ago ago

      Wikipedia articles are randomly sampled, theres no algorithm per-se yet but hoping to collaborate with others to see that through

  • FergusArgyll 37 minutes ago ago

    I've never used tiktok, if this is an accurate representation, it's jarring!

  • aizk a day ago ago

    Hi there, creator of Wikitok here! Very happy to hear that my random little project inspired you :) The attention to detail in the UI is good - I'm so over every default AI generated UI being rounded corners, centered divs, blue and purple gradients, etc. Nice work.

    • sdan a day ago ago

      Thanks! Half of the work here was getting gemini to generate reasonable canvas animations within the window. I'm still experimenting which "style" I should keep/add

  • sdan 20 hours ago ago

    Note there's a rate limit on generated content for the time being, why you're unable to see any new content on the rest of the feeds. LLMs are expensive!

    • baby 15 hours ago ago

      Ad ads like instagram reels have!

  • mappum 19 hours ago ago

    Missed an opportunity to name it WikWok or Tikipedia.

    • sdan 19 hours ago ago

      great suggestion ! i might change it to wikwok, so good

    • raleighm 19 hours ago ago

      WikWok is tremendous

  • tylervigen 20 hours ago ago

    Hilarious. The one AI voice is a little too grating for me, but with a little variation I might actually scroll it for a while.

    • Imustaskforhelp 20 hours ago ago

      Yea I didn't like the voice as well, it felt very coarse to me and not very enjoyable

      To be really honest, I still occasionally browse shorts sometimes because of some youtubers/niche content (there is this really good etymology shorts guy and a fun fact guy I watch usually)

      So like the other day I was asking fun fact about niche legal laws just out of curiosity if anyone of them might be interesting/genuinely helpful to me lol to chatgpt about different countries

      There were lot of niche things but one which I found interesting was that its possible in finland and other norweigian countries to browse even private land / private forests etc. and finland even has a digital right to internet

      > Finland was the first country in the world to make access to high-speed internet a legal right, establishing this policy in July 2010. The law requires all service providers to offer a minimum internet speed of one megabit per second to every household, with a goal of providing access to 100 megabits per second by 2015. PBS edri.org (from Duckduckgo AI)

    • ingatorp 10 hours ago ago

      They could have used Kokoro which is open source, fast and way more human-like.

    • sdan 20 hours ago ago

      A few months ago I made a (theoretically) infinitely learning geo-guessing model that updated the policy with each user guess: https://geospot.sdan.io/

      Hoping to implement a simple RL loop here and optimize whats generated by the LLM to create the perfect slop machine :)

  • fitnessapp 3 hours ago ago

    The idea is really interesting the implementation sucks.

  • kerisi a day ago ago

    you can use LTX to generate the videos, this video took 15s on a 4090

    https://vimeo.com/1152992073?share=copy&fl=sv&fe=ci

    • sdan a day ago ago

      nice did you make this just for the comment? haha

      • kerisi 20 hours ago ago

        yep haha

    • gregjw 20 hours ago ago

      we live in an era of frictionless slop creation. yay.

  • nephihaha 9 hours ago ago

    Google should buy Wikipedia and be done with it. Or we could cut out Google altogether and just search Wikipedia because it is one of the few sites Google will show you.

    • tyleo 8 hours ago ago

      Day 1: Google buys Wikipedia

      Day 100: Wikipedia is shut down

      • nephihaha 5 hours ago ago

        Google would probably asset strip it for all the info it could sell on or import into AI models.

      • thevillagechief 7 hours ago ago

        Google knol

  • vedmakk a day ago ago

    This is really cool. I'm interested in the GenUI part. Is the web app itself static and the stories are generated on-demand?

    Do you give gemini some UI components/templates to build with or is it just prompting to get consistent results across multiple stories?

    • pests a day ago ago

      Google AI Studio has a Gallery[0] with some similar apps. It's an editor so you can view the code, they are usually react apps with gemini integration via genai package. Like this one here[1] is similar. It generates interesting stories to share about a route you are driving / walking / biking along. This is one of the pre-made examples I believe, I didn't make it or anything. Just to show some how some of this might work.

      [0] https://aistudio.google.com/apps?source=showcase&showcaseTag...

      [1] https://aistudio.google.com/apps/bundled/echo_paths?showPrev...

    • sdan a day ago ago

      Yes I have base css/js that I inject on top of whatever codegen gemini 3 comes back with -- It runs via ai-sdk so the specific function is streamObject which is prompted to generate inner HTML elements

  • exomonk 14 hours ago ago

    Can you request a specific wiki article?

    I'd like to see https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Dome_(missile_defense_syst...

  • Edmond a day ago ago

    Work related versions of this, expense report:

    https://youtu.be/h0Bg-lqNlkU

    In general Just-In-Time app generation is a bad idea. The right approach is to create human-in-loop tools that a bot would recognize and invoke as needed, of course the human-in-loop tool would itself be AI generated.

    Example of human-in-loop tool in use:

    https://youtu.be/srG5Ze7mS7s

  • breadchris 18 hours ago ago

    I love this! I made a cooking knowledge brain rot app for myself from my favorite youtuber https://recipes.justshare.io/random-dan

  • omegabravo 16 hours ago ago

    I was confused why someone would possibly configure the voice to be quiet and raspy.

    Seems like there's an issue with Firefox that was causing it. Chrome voice sounds "normal" - like TikTok.

  • keepamovin 7 hours ago ago

    That's awesome man that is REALLY cool. Useful :)

  • vishnuharidas a day ago ago

    Coincidentally, I was vibe-coding a doom-scroller for Hacker News Top Stories today: https://vishnuharidas.github.io/hn-reels/

  • cornonthecobra a day ago ago

    The caption highlight timing is very inaccurate. It looks like it just steps through each word on a fixed timer, rather than using timing information from the TTS engine?

    • sdan a day ago ago

      Yes just fixed timer, and using browser TTS nothing fancy here on purpose - when I did some research on tiktok videos generally simpler/worse quality seemed to be better XD

      • cornonthecobra 8 hours ago ago

        In this case, static text without the highlighter would have been better. Because the timing is so far off, the highlighter interferes with reading the captions for hearing assistance.

  • grugagag 20 hours ago ago

    Good. However, on a smaller phone such as Iphone SE the viewport gets cropped all around and I don’t see around 20% of the content.

  • maxbond 20 hours ago ago

    Having a generated voice tell me about some historical massacre in a chipper tone with a generated infographic and set to TikTok music was. Especially dystopian.

    As an experience I found it nauseating and am never doing it again, but as an art piece I give it high marks. Good job.

    • gregjw 20 hours ago ago

      Indeed.

  • furyofantares a day ago ago

    Reading it with sound off is really hard because of the way the words come up one at a time, rather than the whole sentence at once.

  • bstsb a day ago ago

    wow, my attention span is terrible - the first time i tried watching a generated video, i instinctively held the right side of the screen to speed it up to 2x…

    is there scope for allowing users to search for / ask about specific topics? although then you do have to think about security issues with prompt injection

  • anotherpaul 17 hours ago ago

    Oh I hate it it's so brain rotty. Well done. Well done indeed.

  • alexpadula 18 hours ago ago

    It’s a cool idea but the content needs to be more useful imo.

    • sdan 18 hours ago ago

      how could i make it more useful? different formats? would you want to keep you engaged for longer? entertained for longer?

      • garyfirestorm 18 hours ago ago

        Relevant content - what is relevant to me may not be relevant to you.

  • eastbound 8 hours ago ago

    It lacks superlatives. “Discover how [the amazing] [secret|mystery] that no-one [wants to tell you|ever discovers]” should be the first sentence.

    Hopefully it will not make its way upstream in Wikipedia.

  • oceansky 21 hours ago ago

    Very cool! But text moves way too fast

  • cramcgrab 9 hours ago ago

    How appropriate

  • ram_rattle a day ago ago

    Looks super cool

  • lukebechtel a day ago ago

    Honestly, pretty cool.

  • nseth a day ago ago

    Another sick Surya project, well done dude!

    [Neall]

    • sdan a day ago ago

      thanks

  • emsign a day ago ago

    Nice tech demo but in practice utterly annoying and without purpose. I mean don't you think enshitifying Wiki knowledge kind of beats the purpose of acquiring knowledge?

    • odie5533 a day ago ago

      It's a proof of concept to pave the way. I could see benefit in having series which deep dive into material. This felt too shallow to me.

      • emsign 14 hours ago ago

        Deep dives with TikTok mechanics? That's not going to work, that TikTok UI was optimized for dopamine release. You want to teach junkies new things? All they learn is how to get their kicks, so outside that settings nothing will stick. When they have to apply the infotainment snippets in a real world setting the won't be these high reward stimuli. I mean if you want to hook them on feeling great while believing they've learned something...