57 comments

  • Animats 2 years ago ago

    "But those clouds and servers will not be maintained indefinitely, and once they go down, the cars that depend on them will lose features that owners may be relying upon."

    This may prevent cars being advertised for "sale" in California after January 1.

    AB 2426: Consumer protection: false advertising: digital goods.[1]

    “Digital application or game” means any application or game that a person accesses and manipulates using a specialized electronic gaming device, computer, mobile device, tablet, or other device with a display screen, including any add-ons or additional content for that application or game.

    That's a car with an infotainment system.

    This law makes it a crime to offer something "for sale" if it can be remotely disabled later, absent a separate acknowledgement that it's a lease.

    [1] https://legiscan.com/CA/text/AB2426/2023

    • consteval 2 years ago ago

      > This law makes it a crime to offer something "for sale" if it can be remotely disabled later

      Solution: stop making vehicles require constant updates and live servers.

      The entire point of Android Auto and Apple CarPlay is that you can outsource this task to a device that has a MUCH higher guarantee of support, software quality, and connectivity.

      A car infotainment should be able to play local music, control car functions, listen to the radio. None of these require connectivity. You need connectivity for streaming music and GPS. Well phones are really, really good at that.

    • dceddia 2 years ago ago

      Somehow this feels like it could backfire spectacularly.

      “Sorry, we can’t ‘sell’ our cars anymore. The law says we have to call them a ‘lease’ and that’ll be be $X,XXX/year”

    • eigart 2 years ago ago

      How does Tesla sell vehicles in California then?

  • Habgdnv 2 years ago ago

    Just in case someone from American Lease is reading this, I’d be willing to migrate their servers for less than a million.

    Jokes aside, after reading the comments here, I doubt anyone with technical knowledge would believe this. Even with certificate pinning, you can simply dump the firmware as a raw binary, replace the certificate with your own, and upload it back to the car.

    And even if the source code is lost, you can still sniff the traffic and implement an API. I did this for my previous employer, who had a collection of expensive, locked devices. It took me about a week, without any prior knowledge or experience. Imagine what someone with more experience could do...

    • magicalhippo 2 years ago ago

      > Even with certificate pinning, you can simply dump the firmware as a raw binary, replace the certificate with your own, and upload it back to the car.

      That's assuming they have access to the private key used to sign the firmware though...

    • aeturnum 2 years ago ago

      I suspect this has less to do with the ability to...put the software on another VM and more to do with licensing issues.

    • napierzaza 2 years ago ago

      [dead]

  • sverhagen 2 years ago ago

    It would be nice to understand what "can't" means in this context. Are they not technically able to achieve it (which may be overcome by bringing in other technical experts), is it a DNS issue (ha-ha), or is there a licensing issue with some component they integrated with?

    • randerson 2 years ago ago

      I've can't imagine any technical situation short of "we lost the source to the in-car software, which is pinned to a certificate only installed on our server, which only one guy had the password to, and he kept it only in his memory, and he died".

    • Palomides 2 years ago ago

      I strongly suspect everyone who knew their infrastructure was laid off (or quit), so there's no chance of a technical handoff

    • abound 2 years ago ago

      The first thing that came to my mind was "cert pinning and someone lost the private keys", but that seems pretty unlikely in the grand scheme of things that can go wrong.

      I'd actually be willing to pick one of these up for a 70%+ discount if it came with all the internal schematics and source code, server migrations be damned.

    • davesmylie 2 years ago ago

      I read that as "technically we can't do this as we don't have the money"

    • mlhpdx 2 years ago ago

      Likewise, is it strictly "we can't" or "you can't, either" -- the former would be a legal issue whereas the latter might be an tech/IP issue (ownership of PKI and, yes, DNS).

    • jcgrillo 2 years ago ago

      Yeah...

      > Fisker informed American Lease that the Oceans "cannot, as a technical matter, be 'ported' from the Fisker server to which the vehicles are currently linked to a distinct server owned and/or controlled by" American Lease.

      "as a technical matter" is doing a lot of work in that sentence... I have questions.

    • 2 years ago ago
      [deleted]
    • sam1r 2 years ago ago

      Right, "technically" not theoretically, it is absolutely still possible. This almost always alludes politics.

    • emmelaich 2 years ago ago

      Yes, 'technically' sounds like bullshit.

      It could be something as simple as the server ip address in each car's firmware. That's annoying but not insurmountable.

  • throwaway48476 2 years ago ago

    In a way I'm glad fisker went bankrupt if only to provide proof positive of the dangers of the 'connected car'.

    • johnnyanmac 2 years ago ago

      >The company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in June after failing to reach a strategic agreement with another automaker that could provide it with more capital and domestic manufacturing capacity.

      I don't think software had anything to do with the filing. they couldn't make and sell cars fast enough and burned through their money over the pandemic.

  • walrus01 2 years ago ago

    A good reminder to never buy a high-dollar tech product that you don't actually own because its continued functioning is dependent upon phoning home to some corporate overlord. I'm happy with my shitty old non-tech-laden car, thanks.

    • deely3 2 years ago ago

      So, just never use any online service. Its a good solution, and so simple!

  • h0l0cube 2 years ago ago

    Are there yet any EVs out there where you actually have control over the software? Or are there any where you could conceivably root the firmware and use open source updates and 3rd party services when the support timeline ends or the manufacturer folds?

    • beAbU 2 years ago ago

      My 2019 Hyundai Kona electric is a "dumb" car. Does not even have built-in nav. There is no connectivity, no app, no spying. Hyundai can vanish from existence tomorrow and the car would not even be aware of this happening. I don't care about it's software, because there is nothing to care about.

      It's just a dumb-ass car that goes when I need it to go.

      It comes with (wired) Android Auto, which is probably it's nicest and most advanced user feature.

    • jve 2 years ago ago

      Nissan Leaf Visia owner here. The car is the most basic of 4 trim lines. I installed Nissan app and couldn't connect the car and found out that connectivity feature is not available for my basic car.

    • frogblast 2 years ago ago

      My 2019 Kia Niro has some not-worthwhile connected service you can simply say No to. It is then a fully offline car. Assigning ownership involves handing someone the key fob.

  • willcipriano 2 years ago ago

    My dream job is solving "impossible" technical problems like this rapidly, on short notice, and eating everything I kill (I'd imagine they could pay $500k+ for a fast [24 hours] solution here).

    Some sort of tech navy seal.

    • anonzzzies 2 years ago ago

      My company has been doing exactly that for decades. We don't work like you suggest; we charge by the hour and the price is based on the tech, difficulty and urgency. For cases like this it would be €1000/human/hr probably. We also ask intake money. We generally don't work on-site but we can and have been flown in, as far as Australia (we are in the eu); those add a lot of costs. We usually have a handover to the existing or new team, so projects are usually a few weeks to max 3 months (we refuse longer; we specify this in the contract; if it runs over, it's their problem, we are out; it helps getting large companies to cooperate and cut red tape as they tend to find it enough we are there and paying the fees for years if it keeps it all running; I hate that so not doing it).

    • sneak 2 years ago ago

      I’ve been that guy. It’s fun but it’s not all it’s cracked up to be.

      The kinds of people who call you are some of the human beings you would least like to work with, generally. They are almost definitionally over-funded and under-prepared.

    • wmf 2 years ago ago

      I would guess the root of this problem is that they aren't willing to pay.

    • neom 2 years ago ago

      I think this must be an engineers wet dream? I'm not a SWE but over the years many engineers have told me that is their dream job.

    • fragmede 2 years ago ago

      That would be pretty fun. Joe Grand has made a career of it, I'm sure there are others.

    • xvector 2 years ago ago

      That sounds like a fun company idea tbh

    • yieldcrv 2 years ago ago

      Yeah form an LLC and pretend there are a bunch of people involved to land that contract

      They wont typically pay an individual a rate equivalent to that, but an LLC can get a contract

  • lykahb 2 years ago ago

    I'd guess that making the cars depend on the cloud so much that they are unusable without it is intentional and was a part of the pitch deck.

  • TheRealPomax 2 years ago ago

    I guess they're handing over full control of those servers, then. Seems a pretty simple problem to solve, given the legal mandate Fisker is under?

  • NotYourLawyer 2 years ago ago

    I don’t understand the issue. Just transfer the domain names and the servers to the buyer. Problem solved.

    • danpalmer 2 years ago ago

      They might have been licencing third party software that can't be migrated in this way due to contractual limitations.

      I imagine the simplest technical solution is for the leasing company to acquire the whole business entity. That may even be what they are trying to do in court.

    • magicalhippo 2 years ago ago

      They're not buying the company though, just a bunch of cars as I understood it. At least several other people have bought Fisker cars as well, perhaps that's where the issue arises.

      At the very least, it sounds like a problematic privacy and legal issue for regular Joe to have his car suddenly send data to some "random" third party, without his consent.

  • jandrewrogers 2 years ago ago

    Analogues of this have been playing out in other industries for some time. The legal incentives strongly bias the outcomes toward it not being possible to own these products, only rent them. At a visceral level I don’t like it but at an intellectual level I understand why it is the only plausible way forward. There is no easy solution.

    In automotive, it is common for there to be a requirement that software is supported to some degree for 7-15 years. In practice, this is extremely expensive to guarantee but no one wants to pay for the cost of a reliable guarantee. The industry is at an impasse with consumers and it manifests in situations like this article.

    • pas 2 years ago ago

      I like renting cars, I hate to take them for some godforsaken garage to fix some issue with it. Sure, there's a premium, and so on, but similarly I hate looking for an overnight parking space, if I can simply hand it over to someone who takes/needs it for the night (going around selling drugs or going to fill it up and clean it, or all of the above) all the better.

      with onboard telemetry and ubiquitous HD image recording ability it's pretty easy to make a few shots to have some evidence of good and careful handling, and giving it to the next user in a known condition.

      of course if time and space are at a relative abundance then owning might make perfect sense, or if someone uses it so much that handover costs would start to be significant.

      7-15 years is nothing for firmware. the hardware is fixed, requirements are also basically fixed. no need to support new codes, new protocols, etc.

  • gjsman-1000 2 years ago ago

    Reminder for anyone here who has imposter syndrome:

    Highly paid engineers built a system this way.

    I also have doubts they were specifically instructed to make the infrastructure non-transferable.

    • cr3ative 2 years ago ago

      I’m not overly surprised that in a startup, there was no mechanism built to split off a small defined portion of their fleet to a different, independent cloud.

      Bit different to changing the whole infrastructure out for every car in a disaster recovery situation.

    • mbreese 2 years ago ago

      I’m also pretty sure they never expected to have to support transferring a car to a different infrastructure. Because if they ever needed to, that meant the company failed. Oh wait…

    • steve_adams_86 2 years ago ago

      Are we sure they were highly paid? Maybe that was part of the problem.

  • hn72774 2 years ago ago

    Are there any viable open source electric vehicle initiatives out there yet?

    • bongodongobob 2 years ago ago

      As much as I love OSS I wouldn't want it in my literal daily driver.

      "My car shuts off when I open all the doors"

      "Why would you want it to run? You can't drive with your doors open! Marking as won't fix, working as intended."

      "It's open source! You can fix the code yourself!"

      No fucking thanks. Some things should cost money and have real stakes.

  • numpad0 2 years ago ago

    Is it because someone fired hit [<] and [>] buttons on HSM on the way out, or is it because they’re trying to take control of fractions of the fleet?

    • asteroidburger 2 years ago ago

      The latter one is the most plausible explanation I’ve read yet. Basically, they can’t give away the keys to the kingdom because they’re for the entire kingdom, not just the unsold inventory.

  • LegitShady 2 years ago ago

    cloud features are the enemy of consumers

  • pabs3 2 years ago ago

    Probably a bigger problem for modern cars (including EVs) is how long security updates will be provided for.

    • beAbU 2 years ago ago

      Why would a car even need to have security updates in the first place. Or are we arguing that software updates and patches become like car parts, and you can go to your local parts dealer to get an oil filter, fan belt and a USB with the latest security updates?

    • Ekaros 2 years ago ago

      There should be some reasonable mandate how long security updates have to be provided from last manufacturing date. Say 25 years.

  • kragen 2 years ago ago

    Technical incompetence, it sounds like? The risks of technical incompetence seem to be rising.

  • sublinear 2 years ago ago

    Stop stacking the deck with incompetent opportunist scammers who don't belong in front of a computer let alone managing jack shit especially IT projects. Pure stupidity and downvote me all you want.

  • 2 years ago ago
    [deleted]
  • williamty689 2 years ago ago

    [dead]